Wow thank you everyone for the support and well-wishes! And thank you Couch2Trackula for being thoroughly impressed with me! haha that felt great to hear!!
Yeah, Nicolette, it was a specialty store called Fleet Feet (Rochester, NY). They did the measurements and the treadmill thing and then brought out maybe 5 shoes that they picked for me to try on. They even let me take each one for a run outside! I tried my best to be responsible and pick the one that fit best, rather than the one with the coolest colors haha (seems like bright neon colors are really in right now with running shoes!). I picked the ones that felt most comfortable and natural, but supportive. They were Asics GT-2000 D (wide). I have a mortons neuroma so I need wide shoes. On the website it mentions that they are good for mild to moderate overpronators (rolling in the ankles), so that makes sense. Here's a link if you want to look at them:
http://www.asicsamerica.com/footwear/running-shoes/gt-2000-t2k7n-womens/
And then the inserts that I bought (I think the running store I was at only carries this brand) were Superfeet (the Berry ones designed for women):
http://www.superfeet.com/activity/running-walking/Berry.aspx
I'm sure there are specialty running stores in most cities- I would definitely suggest going to one rather than buying online (unless you already know which shoe you want). That's interesting about the glass box thing in that store in cincinatti- I don't think they had one of those where I went.
Anyway, I went out for my W3D3 run yesterday and I can definitely say that the shoes helped, a lot! I still had some minor knee pain but it did not interfere with my running like it did on W3D2. It felt more like a sore muscle than the sharp, intense pain I was feeling before. I'm hoping that after some time with these shoes the pain will go away altogether. My 17 year old sister came on my run with me, too. It was good to know I could keep up with a 17 year old who is (was) probably in better shape than me due to the fact that she has gym class/ a more active schedule, and I sit at a desk all day. It was nice but I don't think I would want to run with other people all the time, haha.
Yeah... AlmightyD, it is getting cold out there! I'm planning on trying to stick it out and run through the cold with a bunch of layers on. Any way you could leave your kid at home? I'm not a fan of treadmills either- half of the point of running for me is to get outside and enjoy the outdoors, as I spend so much time inside as it is- and even moreso in the winter! Anyone else know any tips or tricks for running in the cold? Is it generally safe?