active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
14 Replies Last post: Jun 20, 2007 10:42 PM by corland14  
Click to view corland14's profile Pro 117 posts since
Feb 7, 2006
Login to Reply

Jun 5, 2007 12:00 AM

Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?

I know this kind of question has been asked dozens of times before, but I'm looking for experiences.

Last fall I ran my first marathon. I've also run (3) 25ks in my brief running career (2+ years). There are 2 marathons this fall that I would like to run, one on 9/30 the other on 10/28. I'm currently running 40+ miles per week. By the end of July I'll be running 50-55.

Am I pushing the envelope? Does anyone out there have a similar experience? I know that there are several experienced runners who run multiple marathons each sping and fall, but has anyone done something similar with little experience?

I'd like to run the first one like a long (long) run. I think I can keep myself from pushing hard..... Thoughts?
Click to view MM Hippo's profile Legend 202 posts since
Apr 28, 2006
1. Jun 5, 2007 9:58 AM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
It entirely depends on what your first marathon recovery was like. Use that as your guide. Lots of people put marathons that close, it all depends on how you respond. Generally, marathon recovery gets a little quicker and more solid each time you do it.

You can use the intervening time to do some light recovery, build back a little, and maybe even a few sharpening workouts to dial in your second race pace. Perhaps the best way to use the two races is to figure out what you could have improved or changed about the first and use the intervening time to dial in any changes.

One other trick is to just not sprint that last mile like everybody does. If you run mile 26 at the same pace you ran mile 25 (instead of sprinting), it will only add about a minute to your time but may make your recovery MUCH easier.

------------------
-Hippo-

We went to face our demons, but all we found were angels.
me[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view PCmarathonmommy's profile Pro 61 posts since
Mar 9, 2006
3. Jun 5, 2007 4:26 PM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
Hi,
I'm planning on doing something similar. I'm running the Park City Marathon and then Top of Utah, they're 3 weeks apart. I'm running park city as a training run and then going to race top of Utah. I'll be done with this a month before yours so I'll let you know :-P
Click to view RunLongVT's profile Pro 163 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
4. Jun 6, 2007 9:39 AM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
Oooh, marathons four weeks apart. This is my specialty :O).

corland14, you can do this. These marathons are far enough apart. The key is to pick the one that is your A race, and treat the other one, as you say, like a long run or victory lap.

I love marathons. Just love them. I run a marathon or 50k about once a month. Four weeks is plenty of time for me, but I am not exploring the limits of my capabilities on any of these runs. If I want to PR, I will take a break for several months leading up to it.

You have the absolutely perfect attitude in your first post. You can do both of these if you treat the first one like a long run, and have the personal discipline not to get caught up and race. The only goal you should be shooting for is your designated long run pace. If you ran hard for your 4:06 PR, as you say you did, I'm not sure trying to better that time qualifies as a reasonable, conservative way to run the first one, but you know your this-year fitness level better than I do. Your goal needs to be simply to complete the run and get to the starting line of #2 healthy and energized. I agree that not kicking it in should help a lot. Don't taper for the first race more than a few easy days, take a week with half milage afterwards, then get in one solid week of training and start your taper for #2.

Alternately, you can race the first one, shoot for that PR, and then cruise through the second one as a victory lap, just to experience the day and put another notch in your belt. There is probably a higher chance of injury with this plan, however, because it just takes a while for your body to be ready to go long after giving it all you've got over the full marathon distance. Perhaps the courses should educate your decision on this one. Also, you may choose to race the first one, and get hit by some terrible weather system the day before, and throttle back your goals. Race number two, in that case, is a backup.
Click to view Ewart_Harris's profile Legend 313 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
5. Jun 6, 2007 2:24 PM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
quote:<HR>Originally posted by corland14:
I know this kind of question has been asked dozens of times before, but I'm looking for experiences.

Last fall I ran my first marathon. I've also run (3) 25ks in my brief running career (2+ years). There are 2 marathons this fall that I would like to run, one on 9/30 the other on 10/28. I'm currently running 40+ miles per week. By the end of July I'll be running 50-55.

Am I pushing the envelope? Does anyone out there have a similar experience? I know that there are several experienced runners who run multiple marathons each sping and fall, but has anyone done something similar with little experience?

I'd like to run the first one like a long (long) run. I think I can keep myself from pushing hard..... Thoughts?
<HR>


I am planning to do the same two marathons. I think its Scotia waterfront and the Toronto Marathon. I broke a metatarsal running Toronto last year (It was my second time running Toronto) I just want to conquer it and do under 3:20. I am going to do Scotia for the first time because it is flat as a pancake and very fast and I want to make sure I Boston qualify this year. With four weeks apart, I think if you do not blow yourself out at the end, you should be able to have a good recovery in time for the last one. Scotia is also very flat and very easy on the body. Good luck!
Click to view spartanrmd's profile Pro 96 posts since
Apr 9, 2004
7. Jun 7, 2007 12:54 AM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
are you just concerned that you wont be 100% recovered???

in 4 weeks your recovered (unless you were injured or a foot fell off or something)

I LOVE running the U.P. (upper michigan) it doesnt get much better than that especially in the fall If I had to make one or the other my A race (which I or you dont) the U.P. would be it

one of the great running motivators in the UP are the deer flys - you cant stop running without getting their attention
Click to view MM Hippo's profile Legend 202 posts since
Apr 28, 2006
8. Jun 8, 2007 10:36 AM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
quote:<HR>Originally posted by corland14:

By the way, my 25k from this spring computes out to a 3:40 marathon with McMillan so the 9min/mile (4 hour) pace is an easy run.

<HR>


Be careful with that. There is a huge fallacy in that logic - a mistake that almost everyone makes.

The McMillan calculator assumes equal training for each distance. But the marathon requires a lot of specific adaptations that can take a very long time to train. In addition, an awful lot of general running people do may act as "training" for a 25K (at least somewhat) but will help very little for the marathon.

So people put in a few months of marathon training against a race that requires lots of training and think this is the equivalent of years of training for a race that requires less training.

They set their pace based on a calculator and then wonder why they crashed.

It is so easy in a training program to find your time expectations creeping. Looking at that calculator might be encouragement for you to do that. If (conservatively thinking) you are in reality only ready to run a 3:55 but manage to convince yourself to shoot for a 3:35 or 3:40 you might have really tough going in the last miles.

And struggling badly through the last miles is NOT a way to be successful at doing two of these with only a medium recovery period.
Click to view Ewart_Harris's profile Legend 313 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
9. Jun 8, 2007 11:01 AM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
Corland14

Listen to MM Hippo he is correct. I know because I have made the same mistake. An additional mistake is that some people on this web site advocate running 2 min per mile slower than marathon pace all the time and some how on marathon day you will be able to run 2min per mile faster. It has neeeveeer worked for me. But that is another story.
Click to view Kevin E. Stroud's profile Legend 512 posts since
Oct 27, 2007
10. Jun 8, 2007 1:37 PM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
Very do-able, and great advice so far.

Last fall I ran Quad Cities Marathon, then four weeks later ran Chicago Marathon, then four weeks later ran the JFK50.

Had the most difficulty in the first race and by the time I got to the last one (a 50 miler) felt great.

Definitely a way to pack some quality running into a short amount of time - and it's off that base that I BQ'ed 8 weeks after JFK50!

kestrou
Click to view bigapplepie's profile We're Not Worthy 2,636 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
11. Jun 8, 2007 1:43 PM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Ewart Harris:
An additional mistake is that some people on this web site advocate running 2 min per mile slower than marathon pace all the time and some how on marathon day you will be able to run 2min per mile faster. <HR>

They do?
Click to view FatHappyRunner's profile Pro 168 posts since
Sep 22, 2005
13. Jun 19, 2007 6:22 PM in response to: corland14
Re: Marathon #2 and #3 in the same month?
quote:<HR>Originally posted by corland14:
Thanks MM Hippo
I ran the first marathon hard, which consequently meant a long recovery. Last year I only had 7 weeks between July and October that were over 40 miles. I battled some nagging injuries. This year, assuming that I'm a smarter runner, will be much better. I'll have a base that should be twice what last years was.

Last year's time was 4:06 on a windy day. I may shoot for a sub 4 hour marathon the first race. Then, if I feel up for it, try the second. If I cant do the second at least I have a PR for the year.

By the way, my 25k from this spring computes out to a 3:40 marathon with McMillan so the 9min/mile (4 hour) pace is an easy run.

<HR>


I did the exact thing you are talking about last year. I had run one marathon previously in 12/05. 4:18

In late Oct of last year I ran MCM in 3:51, turned around and ran White Rock the first weekend of December in 3:45. 5 weeks between races. MCM was brutal for me: had loads of cramping and there were some notable wind issues last year. WR was perfect and I even had a pit-stop of about 3-4 minutes.

Anyway, I basically did what the experts recommend. I did the reverse taper after MCM. I had trained in the 40-50 MPW range and for the three weeks after MCM did about 20-30 MPW, with the longest run being 18. I followed this with another taper and I felt extremely rested heading into WR. I knew my training from the summer would still be there and my goal in the 5 weeks between races was to stay injury free and to maintain that level of fitness I had attained. That being said, I did less miles but many at MP or at least a faster pace than normal. I'm not sure this works for everyone but it did for me. I'll emply a similar strategy this Fall as I attempt to run 3 marathons in 3 months.

Good luck.
FHR