active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
1,198 Replies Last post: Jan 8, 2008 3:34 PM by formationflier   Go to original post 1 ... 9 10 11 12 13 ... 80 Previous Next
Click to view Aetheana's profile Amateur 13 posts since
Mar 20, 2007
150. Jul 13, 2007 9:56 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
I'm making my way through archive MAF thread #2. Jimmy, you had just hit 100 miles in one week and were very proud. Jesse just did a trail 50 miler where his GPS crapped out and said he ran 317 miles. It's really cool that this thread has been going for so long and you can see the improvements people have made!

One thing that was stressed a lot was this no carbs 3 hours before the run. Does that mean no bread/sugar type carbs? What about the carbs found in veggies or fruit? Meat and fat only?

I overslept and couldn't run this AM. I'm doing a treadmill run this afternoon and need to schedule lunch. I have chicken and bit of cheese and broccoli. Do I need to be overly concerned when I eat it?

Thanks!
~Mary
Click to view Dana Becker's profile Legend 392 posts since
Nov 20, 2007
151. Jul 13, 2007 10:35 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Aetheana:
I'm making my way through archive MAF thread #2. Jimmy, you had just hit 100 miles in one week and were very proud. Jesse just did a trail 50 miler where his GPS crapped out and said he ran 317 miles. It's really cool that this thread has been going for so long and you can see the improvements people have made!

One thing that was stressed a lot was this no carbs 3 hours before the run. Does that mean no bread/sugar type carbs? What about the carbs found in veggies or fruit? Meat and fat only?

I overslept and couldn't run this AM. I'm doing a treadmill run this afternoon and need to schedule lunch. I have chicken and bit of cheese and broccoli. Do I need to be overly concerned when I eat it?

Thanks!
~Mary
<HR>


If you don't eat a large meal, 2 hours is probably sufficient. When I do long runs on the weekend, I will usually have some cereal and then head out a few hours later.

No carbs before running, though. Really, I don't want much of anything in my stomach when I start runs.
Click to view IceStorm213's profile Legend 354 posts since
Nov 1, 2005
152. Jul 13, 2007 11:37 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by dfcameron:
Runner 1967 -

Oh boy, I can chime in here. I ran high school track and XC (although I'm a little older than you) in similar times. My 5K PR was 17:47. My max HR was certainly over 200 then.

Fast forward to today. I'm now 44. My max HR is probably 183. My MAF is about 145. Most of my training is between 9:00-9:30 pace with occasional tempo runs at 7:00 min/mi pace.

I have no doubt that right now (if it were a little cooler) I could break a 3:40 marathon. I've always been able to race a marathon at least 1 min/mi faster than MAF pace for long runs.

5 years ago, just before I turned 40, I ran with friends who often left me behind in training runs. We'd start at 9:00 min/mi pace; and they'd often pick it up to around 8:40. I'd stay at 9:00, because at 8:40 - my HR would edge over what "felt right". Yet... on marathon day, I ran a 3:27, and they ran 3:30-3:35 (depending on person).

Now, with age 45 looming between now and the next Boston, the qualifying time eases to 3:30. I now have a new goal - get under 3:30. I've upped my mileage - ran 257 in April, 264 in May, 260 in June and will build a little more. I need a really strong aerobic base before I get back into speed work.

Sounds like we're similar in ability... So everyone's different; but you can set your sights high if you get the base in using LHR.
<HR>


I'm also in the ballpark age-wise, although less experienced. I ran MCM at @ 86% max HR and National Marathon (DC) at @ 88%. I was 6 minutes faster at National and pushed hard the last 5 miles (BQ). I have a relatively low max HR, so I'm not a MAFF guy, but I do try to follow the low HR principles generally. Having said that, in preparation for National, I cranked up my long runs a notch or two (73% and up to 83% max HR near the end) and did a tempo run each week. Even then, my marathon day runs were faster and easier than those infernal long runs which were almost always at least 1:15 slower per mile, and usually closer to 1:45. I ran fewer miles though -- for whatever reason, I have trouble getting over 50 mpw.

I don't believe, by the way, that your max HR fell 17 bpm over time. Maybe a couple. Max HR is essentially fixed.
Click to view catwoman73's profile Pro 105 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
153. Jul 13, 2007 1:48 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
Hi everyone!

After reading through this thread, and reading all of the posted links, I've decided to give low HR training a try. I'm 34 years old and have only been running for one year. I ran my first HM in May, and am planning to run my second on Sept. 30th. During this past year, I've suffered from all sorts of aches and pains, and I've felt tired all the time. I do get sick frequently as well, and because I work in an intensive care unit, having a healthy immune system is of utmost importance. I want to be a healthy, life-long runner, and that is my biggest reason for giving this a try.

My question for you is- I understand the rationale for eating no carbs immediately before running, but I run first thing in the morning, and have ALWAYS eaten a small meal immediately before setting out on my run (yes- my stomach is made of iron!!!). I do this because I suffer from hypoglycemia, and always wake up absolutely famished! So- how should I approach eating now? Should I eat a couple of eggs before heading out? Or should I head out on an empty stomach, and start taking in small amounts of sports drink once I'm warmed up?

Any advice would be appreciated!

Thanx,
Pam
Click to view slowgino's profile Pro 88 posts since
Jan 13, 2007
154. Jul 13, 2007 2:21 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Runner1967:
OK, maybe I'm just naturally gifted or I'm going to be injury prone for the rest of my running career... but here goes.
<snip>
Twenty odd years ago I was a cross country runner finishing my 5k's in 18 minutes or so with a PR at 17:52, if I remember correctly.
<snip>
I've only been truly running since January/February
<snip>
I'm not a Kenyan by any means but after reading all of this I feel like I have a "leg up" (pun not intended) on many other newbie runners or I'm doing something very wrong.
<snip>
I have a progressive ordering of goals for my training.

1. Finish the marathon.
2. Finish the marathon in under 4 hours.
3. Finish the marathon in under 3:40
4. Finish the marathon and qualify for Boston (3:20 based on my age during my first marathon).

The first two appear to be relatively realistic. The 3rd would be a dream goal. and the 4th, well... probably not my first time out but if you don't set your goals high, you'll always be a bottom feeder.
<HR>


Runner1967 ?

You definitely have a leg up on me, I never could have been an xc or track runner in hs, I was way too slow and have no athletic talent.

Just train the best you can, and don't race so hard you crash or get injured or totally burned out. If you just let what happens on race day happen, and then go with the flow, you'll have the best results.


At age 39 I had been jogging/running for a few years and had just completed a year where I ran consistently about 5 days a week and logged about 2000 miles. Training pace was mostly in the 8:00 - 8:30 range. 1st 21-miler was just adding another 7-mile loop to the first two. Then for my first marathon I was afraid of "hitting the wall" so I ran comfortably at 8:00 pace or so for the first 20 miles. At the 20-mile aid station the guy handing me the cup of water said "Man, you look fresh." That just psyched me up... I said "I FEEL GREAT", and just took off. The adrenaline was pumping, and I started passing people. Not a big marathon, but I passed 219 people between 20 miles and the finish... at a pace of 6:30 per mile or better. What a rush. Finished under 3:20. Most enjoyable marathon ever.

A year and a half after that first marathon, I had stopped using training schedules for a couple months and had just been running for pure enjoyment, just to feel good. No big expectations for the marathon I was going to run... I didn't even make up my mind which one until the day before (I had registered for two, one on Saturday, one on Sunday.) I was late getting there and had to jog over a mile to get to the start on time. It wasn't until a few miles in that I realized I was having a good day, and might be able to achieve one of my long-time goals. Long story short - I ran a 2:57 that day, and was so psyched up to do a sub-3:00 at age 40 that I could only sleep 3 hours that night. I woke up at 2:30 AM, couldn't sleep... still psyched, got my gear, drove 180 miles, and ran the other marathon... somewhat slower at 3:41, but what the heck. Then drove 180 miles home to get some sleep.

Why do I mention this? Well...
1) If I had had a goal of breaking 3 hours that Saturday, I probably couldn't have done it,
2) If I had had a goal of running both marathons, I certainly couldn't have run that 2:57 PR,

But, I did have a long-term goal, however unrealistic it seemed, to maybe someday be able to run a sub 3 hour marathon. Maybe. Someday.

I didn't plan for all that on that particular weekend, but I just let things happen, and went along with the way it worked out.

I like Long Run Nick's suggestion: have a goal of running for the rest of your life. If you do that, all these other things will happen, in due time.

Gino
Click to view Runner1967's profile Expert 45 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
155. Jul 13, 2007 2:54 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
Wow, thanks for that inspiration Gino!

My goals are very elastic. After getting back to running for running's sake, I am enjoying it. The pride of finishing my first marathon will carry me a long way. After the pain subsides, I'll continue. I don't see any reason why I can't get better considering where I'm at today and how much (or how little) I have put into it up to this point. Most of all I have been disciplines (military background) about just getting up in the morning and running. Not for time or pace necessarily but just to get out there and run. I know I will improve simply by running more. There will be a plateau, but it's one that I set for myself!
Click to view dfcameron's profile Pro 122 posts since
Apr 5, 2007
156. Jul 13, 2007 4:29 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by martinjames:
I don't believe, by the way, that your max HR fell 17 bpm over time. Maybe a couple. Max HR is essentially fixed. <HR>


Strong disagreement here. The "rule of thumb" (which has wide variance) is that Max HR is 220 minus age.

For me, and for all my friends ( that measure heart rate ), max HR is fixed over a short period of time - but over years, steadily declines. It may not be "one beat per year", but it definitely declines.

For me (when in shape), and 8:00 min/mi pace corresponds to a heart rate of between 155 and 160. The problem is, when I was 25, that was only about 78% of max HR - and I could keep it up for a long time w/o waste buildup. Now, its 86% of max HR - and if I do a longish run at that pace, I'm whipped for days afterward. Eventually, when I'm 65, that WILL be my max.
Click to view dfcameron's profile Pro 122 posts since
Apr 5, 2007
157. Jul 13, 2007 4:34 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
Oh yes... to clarify, my initial quote was something to the effect that my max HR was over 200 when I ran in high school. When I got my first HRM (age 29), it was 192. Its currently (age 44) 183. I've tested it periodically via 2-mile track races to get the empirical max.

I certainly don't think Max HR changes much in a few months; but declines slowly over a long period of years.

What's "movable" is the pace you can run at MAF or at varying heart rates - up to a point. Once you've got years of a strong aerobic base - it doesn't move much anymore.
Click to view bluelake's profile Pro 66 posts since
Oct 25, 2007
158. Jul 13, 2007 4:42 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
catwoman,
I am a newbie, but I can tell you my experience. I am also hypoglycemic and thought I had to eat before my runs. After reading the threads here, I dedided to give it a try. I have run first thing in the morning without eating with no problerms. Last week I did 12 miles and just sipped a little Gatorade. I didn't eat for an hour after my run and still did well. I actually find I do much better on an empty stomach. If I eat, I end up with bathroom issues. Just my experience FWIW.

bluelake
Click to view Long Run Nick's profile Legend 265 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
159. Jul 13, 2007 5:23 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
Max HR declination. Geez, I've read more conflicting stuff on this over the yrs. Some say it declines with age. Some say the more aerobically fit you get--the lower your Max HR will be.
I was an early Polar HR Monitor guy when they first mass produced them--whenever that was. Seems like a long time ago. My Max HR was 207--noted on various occasions over a lot of years. Last Summer I ran a July 4th 5K--hot/humid--Florida and got my HR to 199. Could I have run harder? I think I could have--but over the years I have found I don't quite push like I use to. So, for me, it appears my Max HR has come down a little. Soon to be 64, with over 31 yrs of consistent running( logging over 64,000 miles). I have come to the conclusion that most of us end up being an experiment of one.

I am enjoying my low HR training and am logging more miles per week (55-60) than I have EVER run. For yrs 50 miles a week was it. Then I dropped to 5 days a week and 40-45 per week for 5-6+ years. It seems to be working. Nick
Click to view Runner1967's profile Expert 45 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
160. Jul 13, 2007 5:45 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Long Run Nick:
I have come to the conclusion that most of us end up being an experiment of one.
<HR>


Ain't that a fact!
Click to view JonFrum's profile Amateur 23 posts since
Jul 13, 2007
163. Jul 13, 2007 6:39 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
I'm just signing in as a new convert to LHR - or "Slow-A$$ed-Running", as I prefer to think of it. I'm 52, and I've got some nasty heart disease in the family, so I need to work on what contributing factors I can control. I've got the "central obesity" thing going - the fancy-pants way of saying pot belly - and I really need to get rid of the visceral fat that I inherited from Dad. He and his two brothers had the same body type, and all had heart trouble, with two gone now. I ran track in HS, and would like to do some road races, but weight loss and cardio health are my priorities. I started today, and found that the hardest part - the only hard part - is keeping the pace. I'm aiming for 128, and bounce between 124 and 134. I'm barely over walking speed, and find it very easy to keep at it. At my old 10:00 pace, I was approaching my max heart rate at 2 1/4 miles, but I did about 3 miles today in the heat and had no problem. I'll see if I can stay faithful and report back any progress in the future.
Click to view catwoman73's profile Pro 105 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
164. Jul 13, 2007 7:44 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone/Mark Allen/Hadd/Mittleman
Thanks for the reply, blue. Its nice to know that there are other hypoglycemics out there using this method successfully.

I think I'm going to take the next week's worth of runs to experiment a little bit, and see what works best for me nutritionally. I have 8 miles planned for tomorrow, and plan to try to run it with a very small, non-carb snack before hand. My next run, I'll try to go without eating, and see how that goes.

Jesse- don't worry- I would never do anything to endanger myself. Since I started running, I've always kept my cell phone handy, in case I crash and need my DH to come pick me up (I'm sure he'd appreciate that at 6:00 a.m. on a Saturday!!!). And I always carry a snack with me, just in case- though I've never had to use it! I've been dealing with this since my early teens, and always make dietary changes with great caution. The timing for this little experiment is actually quite good- I'm in the very early stages of training for my 2nd HM, so none of my runs at this point are terribly long.

Thanks for the great advice, everyone. I'll keep you posted!

Pam