active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
Login to Reply
1 2 Previous Next
Click to view pwinkle's profile Pro 72 posts since
Dec 14, 2007

Jul 16, 2007 3:12 PM

marathon training - no time for strength training??

This is the 2nd summer that i have been training for a fall marathon and I just cant seem to fit in all of the marathon training and continue with my strength training (ST) routine. In the winter i ST 2/wk. I know that the ST helps me with my running so i get very concerned when i get down to 1/wk or even skip a week or 2 of ST during marathon training.

when do you guys fit in the lifting ?? after a run? before a run? on a day off from running? skip it while marathon training? do you still train legs? when i do, my legs are like lead the next day for my run - recovery issue?


advice - suggestions - thoughts - thanks
Click to view Kevin E. Stroud's profile Legend 512 posts since
Oct 27, 2007
1. Jul 16, 2007 4:51 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
The following is just my personal opinion - and I have no expertise in recommending training to others - but it works for me - YMMV!

I never do weightlifting with my legs - EVER! In my opinion, that's only going to tighten what's already tight and lead to injury. For leg strength training I do hill repeats and, on rare occasion, a stairmaster - which is still a close analogue to running.

I'm far from a bodybuilder physique, but I have two weightlifting workouts (all upper body and core) that both take less than an hour when I move fast and don't stand around and talk to everybody in the gym (you know how for some people it seems to be their "social time"? I can't stand that...)

I do workout #1 on Mondays & Thursdays , #2 on Tuesdays & Fridays.

Monday and Thursdays are "off" running days for me - so the only two conflicts are Tuesdays and Friday (so don't do "core" on those days!) and do them before your running.

Nope, not easy to fit in, but that's how the puzzle pieces go together for me!

kestrou
Click to view Nobby063's profile Legend 630 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
2. Jul 16, 2007 9:23 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
quote:<HR>Originally posted by pwinkle:
This is the 2nd summer that i have been training for a fall marathon and I just cant seem to fit in all of the marathon training and continue with my strength training (ST) routine. In the winter i ST 2/wk. I know that the ST helps me with my running so i get very concerned when i get down to 1/wk or even skip a week or 2 of ST during marathon training.

when do you guys fit in the lifting ?? after a run? before a run? on a day off from running? skip it while marathon training? do you still train legs? when i do, my legs are like lead the next day for my run - recovery issue?


advice - suggestions - thoughts - thanks
<HR>


I love Mary, but I love Jane too... What should I do? Any suggestion?

What do YOU want to do? What's YOUR ultimate goal?
Click to view rochey's profile Legend 213 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
3. Jul 16, 2007 9:29 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
I regularly either lift at lunch or in the morning before work, and that didn't change for me during marathon training. I don't ever lift legs because I know I'll be out of commission for at least a day and during marathon training, that doesn't work so well.

------------------
My profile[/URL" target="_blank">
Me[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view runninirish's profile Legend 233 posts since
Feb 26, 2007
4. Jul 16, 2007 10:03 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
quote:<HR>Originally posted by pwinkle:
. I know that the ST helps me with my running

<HR>


This is not true...running helps with running. Now don't get me wrong, I'm in the weightroom 3 times a week religiously...but I am not under the false impression that it is making me a better runner. I'm sure some will argue that it helps with injury prevention and makes you run stronger...but there is not much evidence to support that strength training helps you run faster...(with the exception of good old fashion core-work)...for what it's worth, I do NO leg work in the weight room, but I'll do plyometric stuff when I'm in my "off season"...otherwise I try and lift as a seperate workout-if I have to put them together I lift THEN I run...that's what I've read is best...otherwise I spend about 30 mins x 3 times a week working on core work and upper body. So my arguement is not to sweat it...it you can't get in the weightroom, it should not hurt your marathon performance...

------------------
"Fortitudine vincimus"
Click to view AKTrail's profile Legend 360 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
5. Jul 16, 2007 11:22 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
I don't lift at all (well, except for my hydration pack) and am slow, but do running-specific (and some not so specific) strength training, including submax plyos, in early base then depend on specific running workouts as get closer to races.

Is there any reason why you can't do the gym stuff you want early in training cycle (general), then as you get toward races, get more specific - like doing hill work, i.e. periodize. I mean hills were put on this earth for runners to train on, weren't they? and scenery for long runs.
Click to view runawayjesse's profile Legend 538 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
6. Jul 17, 2007 5:24 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
their is huge debate weather strength training helps running or not. After a self experiement I have found that strength training for me is a must. Some people were born with natural strength others not so lucky. Me being 120 lb male I lack some serious strength. I think it's an indivisul thing really.

What I do is lift weights for strength and power during a base buildup when the miles are at a decent pace. At that time I will place a emphasis on weights lifting 6-10 reps till faliur. As the marathon training gets more intense I will decrease down to 15 repish with sub maxiumal weights. Finally during the last few peak weeks of training I will do general maintenance stuff with lighter weights more reps(like 20ish).

I find it most important to work on the legs though I do work upper body as well. Without strength training I form muscle imbalances so I condition all muscles far beyond the strength it takes to run even a steep hill. I tried just running hills for strength training before. It seems like a good plan..kinda like having your cake and eating it too. For me though it just contributed to the muscle imbalances plus you really limited to how much strength you can gain(unless you overload adding weighted vest).

So in short you need to periodize your weight training. During off season place a good deal of attention to building strength, thats the time to break down as the easy runs aren't too taxing on the same muscle fibers that you use in running. by the time intense training comes about all your fast twitch muscles are conditioned so just do maintenance stuff in the weight room. If you go from strength type lifting to maintenance lifting, the maintenance stuff is like a walk in the park. For me it's 2x 30 min sessions in the gym...thats just enough to maintain the strength I have built yet I can squeeze it in anywhere as it doesn't require recovery. During maintenance it shouldn't be hard because you are no longer training by a progression overload scheme like before,you just stay at the same level. So yes you can have your cake and eat it too.

Good Luck
Click to view dpar's profile Pro 85 posts since
Dec 11, 2005
8. Jul 18, 2007 8:55 AM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
My anecdotal evidence.

I also never lift wieghts, never ever. That stuff is heavy and hard to pick up for crying out loud. Seriously though, maybe I'm built just muscular enough or maybe cycling and running keeps my legs strong enough. Hills and hard efforts are all the extra work my legs get.

------------------
My Log[/URL" target="_blank">

My Profile[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view Kevin E. Stroud's profile Legend 512 posts since
Oct 27, 2007
9. Jul 18, 2007 10:22 AM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
Having huge upper body muscles can indeed be "dead weight" when running if taken to the extreme.

But something to consider is that it's also "potential glycogen storage space"!

kestrou
Click to view baggio16's profile Pro 87 posts since
Aug 14, 2002
10. Jul 18, 2007 2:27 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
I usually lift during lunch M-W-F. I run doubles most days. I never lift legs. There's really no need.

------------------
Click to view mmoonhead's profile Legend 524 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
11. Jul 18, 2007 2:37 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
I've found it helps, not with the running so much as with dealing with the stresses of training in general.

I pretty much stopped all weight training for my first marathon last summer, and I think that (plus dropping a lot of weight the last 10 weeks) helped contribute me feeling pretty weak by race day.

I've kept the strength training consistent this year and I feel much more energized. And I know it's a better fat/muscle weight distribution to boot, because I'm actually 10 lb lighter than this time last year.
Click to view tuscaloosarunner's profile Legend 728 posts since
Apr 7, 2006
12. Jul 18, 2007 3:31 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
quote:<HR>Originally posted by runninirish:
///for what it's worth, I do NO leg work in the weight room, but I'll do plyometric stuff when I'm in my "off season"...

<HR>


Why offseason? Most of the runners on the XC at U of AL downhere do the plyo work in-season. These guys are running 8-10k, though, so the explosive drills might be more apt to them than a marathoner (though not by much).

That said, I periodize strength work. Base strength and core work pre-season; core, plyometrics, and med ball work in season...
Click to view west rock boy's profile Expert 57 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
13. Jul 18, 2007 4:51 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
if it is marathon training, meaning longer miles, you certainly could run to where it is that you do your weight training & consequently run back. yeah, it makes for a longer effort time wise, but that's a key component in marathon training. i run to & from the gym where i do my weight training, other times i bicycle there, but it is a good training tool. good luck.
Click to view runninirish's profile Legend 233 posts since
Feb 26, 2007
14. Jul 18, 2007 4:59 PM in response to: pwinkle
Re: marathon training - no time for strength training??
quote:<HR>Originally posted by tuscaloosarunner:
Why offseason? Most of the runners on the XC at U of AL downhere do the plyo work in-season. These guys are running 8-10k, though, so the explosive drills might be more apt to them than a marathoner (though not by much).

That said, I periodize strength work. Base strength and core work pre-season; core, plyometrics, and med ball work in season...
<HR>


I just found that when training for a marathon I never had a "good" day to fit in plyo work...for me, 70 mpw was all I could handle...when training for short stuff (5-10k) I have used plyo through my training...I also have my xc and track teams do plyo work in-season...

------------------
"Fortitudine vincimus"