active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
Click to view 3chilipeppers's profile Legend 696 posts since
Nov 3, 2007

Aug 13, 2007 4:10 PM

Differences in Sports Drinks

O.K. With the heat rising and my runs and rides getting longer AND my first Oly coming up, I've started to really think about nutrition. What is the difference between the different sports drinks. It seems Accelerade is becoming quite popular at races. I honestly can't stand the stuff. Is it really better for endurance? I drink Gatorade (the plain stuff you get at the grocery store) on the bike, and that seems fine for sprint races and long ride. They have Powerade at the HM I'm doing in February.

What is really the difference between all of them? Is it merely personal preference (what agrees with you or not) or are there really big differences?

BTW, my typical routine is to drink a Frappuccino when I wake up, eat a Clif bar 1 hour before race, and drink Gatorade on the bike. That's really it, and it has worked for me. I pour water over my head on the run and drink whatever else they have. What should I add when doing an Oly? I know I should probably do some gels on the bike to be ready for the run. I don't have much time to work this out, so I need to know where to start. It will probably be in the 90s on race day (it's 99 right now).

Kelli
Click to view TriBob's profile Community Moderator 377 posts since
May 25, 2007
1. Aug 13, 2007 4:14 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
Up to Oly, go with what works. Gatorade is fine. Longer races you may want to think about something with protein.

For heat, I use Thermolyte salt tablets. They have saved my butt many times in the heat. I usually order 2-3 bottles to average out the shipping. http://www.nvo.com/sportquestdir/products/skudetail.nhtml?uid=10032[/URL" target="_blank">

------------------
Help fight MS, sponsor my MS150 ride.[/URL" target="_blank">

Takes Q's, Kicks A's[/URL" target="_blank">
CR Map[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view teacherjen's profile Legend 469 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
2. Aug 13, 2007 4:47 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
Kelli- I can't explain the differences between the different drinks-- I know that I don't like powerade, and gatorade is fine for me unless it's really hot or I'm going extra long, then I need Gatorade Endurance.

You just have to try a bunch of different stuff in typical race weather/circumstances and see what you like best.

Good luck!
jen
Click to view ToddDubya's profile Legend 212 posts since
Jan 26, 2006
3. Aug 13, 2007 4:49 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
I haven't tackled a tri yet, but I do a lot of ride-then-_____s, and I find that a gel every 45 minutes on the bike keeps me going. I also carry Gatorade (basic Lemon/Lime flavor) in my water bottles. A Clif bar before the ride, and depending on what sport's next maybe another if the ride exceeds 2 hrs. I've found my performance/endurance drops quickly if I don't have gels along the way, and I get REALLY cranky. Blood sugar crash? I think so. I recommend gels on the bike to keep your energy up for the run.

As for differences between the drinks, I think Accelerade has soy protein in it and maybe a "better" sugar source, where everything else (read Gatorade, Powerade) are just corn syrup and water, no protein. Accelerade is $$$, and I'd rather put my money into toys than drinks.

FWIW, I rode in the heat yesterday and my usual 2 bottles of Gatorade weren't enough to last the whole ride and I paid for it at the end.

------------------
-Todd
Check Me Out[/URL" target="_blank">
There's plenty of time for rest when you're dead.
Click to view ussoccer's profile Legend 1,748 posts since
Dec 11, 2007
5. Aug 13, 2007 5:04 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
I know not everyone will agree, but I say go with what works and don't worry too much about the composition of the drinks. In other words, if Gatorade works for you, go with it. Just know that hydration is only a part of the equation, where you will want to get in more calories, and if you use salt tabs, then you'd have to worry less about the sodium content and things like that.

You should be fine with any drink of choice and Gu's and PowerBars or substitutes, and if you think you'll sweat way more than normal, then insert a salt tab or two. That should do it.

From my experience, the number one problem athletes have is hydration, where once the get behind with that -- and often they have no idea -- then there body accepts no nutrition, or it gets more picky. And they often think the problem is the fuel source when in fact they've set themselve up to fail all over the place because they were severly dehydrated.
Click to view dana31788's profile Rookie 5 posts since
May 17, 2006
7. Aug 16, 2007 12:39 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
Kelli,

Try Powergel in vanilla. Tastes just like vanilla cake icing! And if you have a bento box on your bike, several will fit in there.
Click to view kcwoodhead's profile Legend 355 posts since
Oct 18, 2007
8. Aug 16, 2007 1:31 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
Kelli - go to RunTex and buy one of every type of gel you think you might like. Then try then out during various training runs/rides.

My personal favorite now is Clif Shot Blocks. I get the orange with caffeine. I also use power gel chocolate flavor too. It has caffeine and added sodium. I tell myself the chocolate at least tastes like something I could possibly eat in the real world (icing, pudding, etc). The tropical flavors and berry flavors and stuff like that for gel don't work for me. The clif blocks are kind of like candy/jello, so the fruity flavors work fine for me.

Another fun one is Jelly Belly sport beans - they have the same nutrition as a gel packet and are like eating candy (albeit salty candy) while you are exercising!
Click to view kcwoodhead's profile Legend 355 posts since
Oct 18, 2007
9. Aug 16, 2007 1:34 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
I forgot 2 things...being in Texas, you might want to think about sodium intake. You can get this in some gels now that have extra sodium, you can take salt tabs, or drink something that is sodium enhanced (i.e. gatorade endurance).

I train with gatorade endurance when I'm not using my infinit.

Also, I should say after you pick a product you like, you can most likely order it online in bulk for a discount, as opposed to always buying it at a running store or REI.
Click to view ksurp's profile Pro 91 posts since
Mar 10, 2006
10. Aug 16, 2007 3:12 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
I order my gu's/Gatorade Endurance mix online from Road Runner Sports. If you buy the VIP membership all shipping is free and they discount from the list price. They also sell running shoes/clothes and the like - worth the membership if you make it a point to buy most of your gear from them.

I've also see the huge canisters of regular gatorade lemon/lime mix at warehouse stores like **'s. I like mixing my own and it has to be less expensive.
Click to view tri_coach06's profile Legend 662 posts since
Aug 14, 2007
11. Aug 16, 2007 4:02 PM in response to: 3chilipeppers
My favorite subject:

I gree with Thor that most athletes have more than enough calories, but do not have near enough water. Each gel requires 4-6 oz of water, that's almost a cup, think abouthow much that really is. Most people take a gel and a sip of water. No good, you need a 1/3 of the bottle. that's 3 or 4 big gulps. That does not include how much you need to replace what you are sweating.

So how much water/hydration do you need. Ideally you would do a sweat test. It's simple. Weight yourself naked before you go out. Measure all the water hydration you take in. weigh yourself when you return. Naked. (If you are more then 2% lighter than your performance has decreased dramatically. Subtract your post race from your pre race weight. A cup (8oz) of water is ~ 0.5lb. (If you had a 20 oz bottle of water it weighs 1.25lbs. ADD that to the lost weight and you know how much you need.

Example ME:

I'm 150 pre exercise. I drink 40oz of fluids and I weigh 145 post exercise. I'm a sweater so those numbers aren't to far from the truth. Anyway, 150-145=5 5 plus the 2.5 from the water is 7.5. I need 7.5 lbs of water to break even.
Almost a GALLON..... Think I'm kidding? Do the test.

That is ME and I do drink that much. I typically bring 2 bottles of 20oz and the Profile drink system up front and my camal bak 70oz and I refill at about 3 hours.

I'm outa work, more later.

Sheldon