active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
Click to view dragonsrouges's profile Legend 1,068 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
16. Dec 25, 2007 5:08 PM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
Oh ok... because that's one heck of a lot of protein, it got me worried.

Back to the original question... I really really believe that if you are going to spend 10-15 hours training per week, it's worth ever minute to spend an hour or so to sit down and prepare your weekly nutrition... so that you don't have to be taking in shakes. I don't think it's really necessary for most athletes for the volume put in.

For elite athletes, it's a different story, because for the same 2 hours of training, they are putting in a heck of a lot more volume and intensity on a daily basis (it adds up) than the rest of the age-groupers. The perceived effort level may be the same but they are putting out a lot more calories and doing much more damage...

For food ideas: I cook up obscene amounts of chicken, beef, fish that I keep in my fridge (once or twice a week) with cut up veggies ready to be cooked. I buy the ready chopped up veggies to go in ommelettes that i make after training and throw it all together to cook while I'm getting dressed/ready to go to work. A few times a week I cook up a batch of lentils and brown rice to go with the protein. In my fridge I keep yogourt, fresh fruit/berries, cottage cheese, soy milk, (all the chopped up veggies)... In the cupboard I keep All-bran Guardian, grape-nuts, all-bran buds, all-bran honey flakes, some canned soup for when I feel like eating salty food and a whole bunch of other things (oh yeah, canned tuna which is good in chick pea and/or bean and/or whole wheat pasta salad). Plenty of protein there.

http://This message has been edited by dragonsrouges (edited Sep-12-2007).
Click to view Caffeinated's profile Legend 234 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
17. Sep 12, 2007 5:19 PM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
quote:<HR>Originally posted by dragonsrouges:
Was that for endurance athletes or stregth/body building athletes?

And how many sources did you find to confirm this figure? I mean normally I wouldn't go through such an extensive bout of research for something that sounds logical but have you researched the effects of this amount of protein on your body? Or at least have you confirmed your finding in Men's Health with other sources?

<HR>


Honestly, I started out reading the 1 to 1.5 grams per pound figure in several publications that pertain to bodybuilding. If you search you will find this advice given like here[/URL" target="_blank"> and here (#3)[/URL" target="_blank"> and here (a bit down the page under "protein"[/URL" target="_blank"> The more I read the less I trusted these sources. I only link them so you can see that those numbers are out there and used by many people. What I saw in Men's Health was the "grams per kilo" number but in my mind I read it the other way. Oops. I do trust Men's Health, they back up their claims with studies. I don't have time or inclination to do the research myself.

Really I'm more of a general guidlines kind of guy. I shoot for eating as well as I can each day and call it good. I don't count calories and I don't worry too much about it. I do take a protein shake after each workout, with glutamine. I take a muti-vitamin and a glucosamine/condroitin (sp?) supplement everyday. If you ask me to back up why I take these things, I won't be able to point to a scientific study, but read many sources and I'm satisfied that they are safe and effective. You shouldn't take my word for it though. I would hope that the OP will keep asking questions and researching until he/she is satisfied that what they are putting into their body is effective and is safe.
Click to view dragonsrouges's profile Legend 1,068 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
18. Sep 12, 2007 5:43 PM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
Hey caffeinated...

I didn't get a chance to read your post about the kilo/pounds before posting mine (i guess you posted while I was writing) but I understand...

I just believe in getting protein from a less processed food source MOST of the time, given the number of hours we put in, I think it's well worth the time to plan out. I don't trust every site and use them as guidelines as well but in this case my common sense told me that the amount was excessive.

But back to the original question, I'd go for the chocolate milk rather than the heavy cream as you said as well... more natural and not as fattening. I suspect better tasting as well!!
Click to view valleysuper's profile Pro 76 posts since
Nov 9, 2007
20. Sep 13, 2007 7:24 AM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
This has turned out to be a good thread on nutrition, and I have wanted to ask another question sort of related. Sorry for the hijack,m843172.

What do you all take for supplementation. I am an age grouper who does ok in triathlon, but I look forward to my gym time more than most. While I am not a bodybuilder I do take it very seriously. I should also state that I do not consider body weight a major factor in my diet and training. I keep more of an eye on hydration and bodyfat, I know it is harder to tri when heavier but I only do sprint tri's and after years I have found the increase in muscle helps me go faster for such a short period of time.

In keeping with the thread I consume 1.5-2 grams of protein per Kilo of BW daily. I start my day with 1/2 cup of whole grain total and a protein shake which is 140 cals and 30g protein. From what I have read and talked about it is important for all athletes to consume some protein upon waking to stop the catabolic process from sleeping. I eat a yogurt, with some benefiber mixed in, and a piece of fruit 3-3.5 hours later. I have a raw spinach and grilled chicken salad, with a cup of fruit and a 1000mg fish oil pill at lunch. Another piece of chicken and 3 Branch Chain Amino Acid pills a few hours later. Post workout I take 5mg of creatine, coupled with another 30g protein shake. If it is a recovery or easy workout I skip the additional protein and just take the creatine. Dinner is what it is, always as healthy as possible, but not too strict. I take 3 more BCAA's and a half of a multivitamin before bed.

I have tinkered with this for a couple of years now and this is what I am doing now. When I am more focused on Tri's I consume a few more calories to keep up with my workouts.
To answer my own question: I take Protein, fish oil, BCAA, creatine, fiber and multivitamin daily.

I am asking as I am always looking to better myself and my workouts, I have such little time to train that I make every workout the best it can be, and recovery is a fickle thing to nail down. I find it is obviously very dependent on the workout duration and intensity, but the things I consume fuel me very well for each day no matter what comes my way,

I love nutrition talk by the way(if this post was not long enough for you to tell), and I fully agree with considering meal preparation a necessary item to schedule and stick to. It is a big part of my week, and one that I share with my kids so that they understand the benefits of eating healthy.
Click to view bcc594's profile Pro 156 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
21. Sep 13, 2007 9:08 AM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
I agree with Dougie Fresh - when I'm in really heavy training, I keep a case of weight-loss shakes in the fridge. When I get home from a workout, I drink one down, which lets me stretch and shower without feeling the need to start chewing on my own arm. Plus, stuff like Slim-Fast, Ensure, or the store brands have a decent mix of carbs and protein, little fat, generally taste fine, and don't bother my stomach after a hard effort as much as some solid foods.
Click to view Caffeinated's profile Legend 234 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
22. Sep 13, 2007 10:52 AM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
quote:<HR>Originally posted by valleysuper:
I should also state that I do not consider body weight a major factor in my diet and training. I keep more of an eye on hydration and bodyfat, I know it is harder to tri when heavier but I only do sprint tri's and after years I have found the increase in muscle helps me go faster for such a short period of time.
<HR>


Valley - How many calories is that total? Seems like with your total activity level, and that you seem to be in control of your nutrition, you should be able to reduce your total calories and lose any extra weight you're carrying.

Also on the creatine. It's my understanding that it's best to cycle off of creatine after a while. A few months on and a few months off.
Click to view valleysuper's profile Pro 76 posts since
Nov 9, 2007
23. Sep 13, 2007 11:35 AM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
Hey caffeinated,

I try and keep my total caloric intake right at about a 5-10% surplus, based on my basal metabolic rate and my calorie expenditure for the day. I am only doing this now as I try and build more size. I am shooting for the 3X300 club we have at my gym this winter(squat, bench, deadlift)
During the race season I try and eat right at my total expenditure so I do not lose too much muscle, maybe a slight deficit to lose those last 3 stubborn pounds before a race. For me in order to gain or lose weight it comes down to the amount of muscle I am carrying. I am right at about 7.5-8% BF so I try not to lose much weight during the season, but I do fluctuate between 174 lbs in season to 190lbs off season, but it is mostly muscle that I gain.

Today for instance I am shooting for about 3300 calories total, I wont know the actual number until after my brick this afternoon. But by keeping my intake mostly the same day to day until dinner time it allows me to correct the total with my dinner choices. If I went longer or harder than planned I will just have a bigger serving at dinner or maybe some ice cream with the kids.

As far as the creatine I can only quote some of the articles I have read, and they are mostly for bodybuilding so I am not sure how it would relate to endurance training. I will look it up and post up a link later on today.
Click to view dragonsrouges's profile Legend 1,068 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
24. Sep 13, 2007 11:59 AM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
I don't think creatine is for everyone, and I also think there are lots of other things that you can do that will have a much bigger ROI (and safer) than taking creatine... If it was that great, every elite triathlete would be on it...

http://www.wellnessletter.com/html/ds/dsCreatine.php[/URL" target="_blank">

A few of my teammates qualified for and competed at Ironman Worlds in Hawaii and none of them are on creatine, they just plan out their meals very well, they don't even take protein supplements. It can be done!
Click to view dragonsrouges's profile Legend 1,068 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
26. Sep 13, 2007 1:52 PM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
I think we complicate things un-necessarily... It shouldn't be this difficult. If it's this hard now, imagine when you're trying to take off a split second off a swim/bike/run time... how complicated a science that must be.

If an average or even above average age-grouper is supplementing this much on protein, by the same ratio, for the extra mileage/volume, how much would an elite triathlete have to consume?!

http://www.foodandsport.com/protein.htm[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view Caffeinated's profile Legend 234 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
27. Sep 13, 2007 4:30 PM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
quote:<HR>Originally posted by dragonsrouges:
I think we complicate things un-necessarily... It shouldn't be this difficult. If it's this hard now, imagine when you're trying to take off a split second off a swim/bike/run time... how complicated a science that must be.

If an average or even above average age-grouper is supplementing this much on protein, by the same ratio, for the extra mileage/volume, how much would an elite triathlete have to consume?!
<HR>


But it's fun! Everyone is looking for that little edge. Look at the time people spend debating whether to wear socks or not, just to save a few seconds.

The thing about comparing age-groupers to elites is that they generally have only one job: be fast in triathlons. If I had a coach and nutritional advisor around to guide me, had the time available and the motivation that comes from having my income depend on it; I'd eat well enough to not require supplements too. And, usually anyway, creatine is not something that I've ever really heard of being used outside of weightlifting circles.

I eat well, and I'd bet most of us on this board eat pretty well too, especially compared to the rest of the population at large (no pun intended). Knowing I can grab a protein shake when I want to gives me the freedom to enjoy that pizza when I might otherwise choose something healthy. (My income doesn't depend on being fast in triathlons.)
Click to view dragonsrouges's profile Legend 1,068 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
29. Dec 25, 2007 5:08 PM in response to: m843172
Re: Does anybody use protein shakes?????
quote:<HR>Originally posted by caffeinated:
But it's fun! Everyone is looking for that little edge. Look at the time people spend debating whether to wear socks or not, just to save a few seconds.

The thing about comparing age-groupers to elites is that they generally have only one job: be fast in triathlons. If I had a coach and nutritional advisor around to guide me, had the time available and the motivation that comes from having my income depend on it; I'd eat well enough to not require supplements too. And, usually anyway, creatine is not something that I've ever really heard of being used outside of weightlifting circles.

I eat well, and I'd bet most of us on this board eat pretty well too, especially compared to the rest of the population at large (no pun intended). Knowing I can grab a protein shake when I want to gives me the freedom to enjoy that pizza when I might otherwise choose something healthy. (My income doesn't depend on being fast in triathlons.)
<HR>


Well that's not always true... a few of my friends are elites and hold regular jobs, one in software development of all fields (long unpredictable hours). A teammate of mine swam at World Championships (FINA) in 2005 (not masters) and held a job and was a student. After his race, he had to go back to work in the afternoon. I guess his boss didn't give him the entire day off. This is why I say that it's possible, I see it around me.


http://This message has been edited by dragonsrouges (edited Sep-13-2007).