active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
Login to Reply
1 2 Previous Next
Guest

Nov 29, 2007 9:01 PM

How long was it before you started to lose weight?

Hi everyone. I am on wk5d1 (although I repeated 2 weeks) and am feeling pretty good. I actually look forward to my running days now which I NEVER thought was possible when I first started the program. I feel like my shape is changing and I more fit, but I'll be darned, I haven't lost even 1 pound! When can I expect to see the numbers on the scale drop? Thanks
Click to view TedAndresen's profile Legend 233 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
1. Nov 29, 2007 9:10 PM in response to: Guest
Running does not make you loose weight, cutting you caloric intake does. Do the math.

You only loose 100 calories per mile when you run, on average. One pound is about 3500 calories. You'd have to run 35 miles to loose a pound.

I suggest that you look at your caloric intake and see if you can substitute some lower calorie foods of the present foods you are eating.

Maybe more fruits and veggies would help.

Ted
Click to view AEK702's profile Amateur 31 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
2. Nov 29, 2007 9:20 PM in response to: Guest
I started losing immediately because I joined Weight Watchers the same time I started running. One mile of running only equals about 100 calories, so while you are on C25K you are not logging enough miles to see a weight difference. Running motivates me to eat right, if for no other reason than I get tired of hauling around the extra pounds. There are several weight loss threads on this board, there are lots of us out there who are running with you so feel free to stop by and say hello!
Click to view dg12002's profile Legend 622 posts since
Aug 26, 2003
3. Nov 29, 2007 9:29 PM in response to: Guest
My weight drops slowly when I get to 45+ mpw without altering my caloric intake.
Click to view figbash's profile Legend 620 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
4. Nov 29, 2007 11:19 PM in response to: Guest
Consider yourself lucky, many new runners actually gain weight when they start running. You'll start losing when you realize that how much you eat determines your weight not how much you run.

Consider the fact that the C25K program maxes out at about nine miles a week. Depending on your weight, that only equals about a thousand calories a week. You can easily offset that amount with one trip to your favorite fast food restaurant.

Running at a beginners level does not justify or require you to eat more and unless you combine it with responsible eating habits you will not lose weight. I've trained for a number of marathons and during that training I only lose around 10 pounds (5% of my body weight) and that's from running up to 50 miles a week.

Run for fitness, eat less to lose weight.

Tom

------------------
My Profile[/URL" target="_blank">
My Running Log[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view jennicap05's profile Pro 147 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
5. Nov 30, 2007 9:44 AM in response to: Guest
I am on week 6 of the OHR (one hour runner) and haven't lost a pound. But I haven't changed my eatting habits at all AND I've measured myself. I've lost a whole inch on each thigh, 1/2 inch around my waist and 1/2 inch around my neck.... I suggest you do the same. I don't have a drastic amount to loose so I know it'll happen in time. I am currently amping up my weekly milage to 20 miles per a week and hope to see a larger drop once I'm running 20 plus a week.

------------------
-Jen
My Profile[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view mrinertia's profile Legend 1,356 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
6. Nov 30, 2007 1:44 PM in response to: Guest
Changed my eating habits and started running at the same time so I started losing right away.

Figbash is spot on.
Click to view mark capparella's profile Expert 57 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
7. Nov 30, 2007 1:48 PM in response to: Guest
Running is a great way to get fit and MAINTAIN your weight, but for real weight loss, you need to cut calories.

When I started running after a LONG time away (15 years), I lost about 50 lbs in 5-6 months. Losing 10 lbs/month (2.5 lbs a week pretty consistantly thoughout the 5 month period) was just about as fast as I'd recommend. Some of the "tricks" I used to help were:

(1) established a good daily caloric intake for gradual weight loss (there are websites that are helpful)

(2) kept a food journal with caloric values to make sure I stayed on track, and to help me be more mindful of "extra" eating

(3) drank a LOT of water throughout the day; 4 X 16 oz bottles at least a day. I'd fill all the bottles at the start of the day, so I'd know how many I'd gotten through as the day went on. I don't like the taste of water, so I added a small amt of a low (or no) calorie flavoring like propel or fruit-2-O to each bottle

(4) brush your teeth AS SOON AS you finish supper. I found this to be one of the best ways for me to avoid my biggest dieting challenge -- post-supper grazing. Once I brush my teeth, I am DONE eating for the night.

As soon as I hit my goal weight, I kind of stopped the dieting, and have been at my goal weight for almost 2 years now. I run about 50 mpw.

Good luck.
Click to view moppet's profile Pro 128 posts since
Sep 25, 2007
8. Nov 30, 2007 4:56 PM in response to: Guest
Running makes me hungry - I've gained weight since i started 3 months ago....
Click to view LPH53's profile Pro 75 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
9. Nov 30, 2007 7:31 PM in response to: Guest
combination of diet and runing. I started running 4 years ago,but only really started loosing weight this year when I changed my diet . However my intensityincreased this year as well, so was it the intensity that made me loose weight or the weight loss that allowed me to increase my intensity
Click to view acronium's profile Amateur 17 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
10. Nov 30, 2007 7:52 PM in response to: Guest
I will echo what everyone else has said - I have not lost a significant amount of weight since I began running (been in it for about a year).

However, my clothes began to fit more loosely after about three months, and my blood pressure and pulse have dropped dramatically over the course of the year. My spouse says I look better, even at basically the same weight.

I think a lot of the posts in this thread are really trying to get across that you shouldn't expect to lose weight solely from running, and I agree with that. But I wouldn't want you to lose heart and decide running isn't worth it.

The health and fitness improvement alone is so worth it. Some posts I read on this topic are kind of moribund in the attempt to set one's weight-loss expectation to the extent that they undersell the fitness benefits.

I feel great since I started running. Don't get bummed out about not losing weight without changing your eating habits. I'm focusing on fitness, and that has made a dramatic enough difference in my life.
Guest
11. Nov 30, 2007 9:23 PM in response to: Guest
I think that while the majority of the answers have been well intentioned, they have been misleading. Based on what the OP stated, it seems pretty clear that he/she is losing pounds of fat and gaining muscle. This is very common when you start running and I think you should take heart in knowing that it's working.

Depending on your starting point, it's likely to be weeks before the number on the scale comes down but you'll notice that people will tell you that they can tell how much weight you lost (and you'll be thinking..."Yeah, like one whole pound.")

Then one day, the magic will kick in. Because of the added muscle, your body will burn more calories at rest and your workouts will add to it. Then you'll probably start to see 1-3 lbs coming off per week.

Of course you need to watch your intake but the previous responses seem to suggest you need to join weight watchers to lose any weight. That's not the case at all.

I played football for years but now I'm 40 and everyone has heard the story about guys who blow up because they still eat like they're at the training table...that's me. Despite taking in 3,000-4,000 calories per day, I'm still dropping weight with regular running and cycling.
Guest
12. Dec 1, 2007 12:14 PM in response to: Guest
I have been running for four weeks and have lost a little weight (5 pounds) but I notice my legs are stronger and leaner, and my stomach (always a fun spot for me as it is for my mother and was for my grandmother - don't you love genetics) is actually getting less floppy. It's almost like your body goes "she's doing this running thing and all those floppy bits don't feel right so I guess I better tighten them up."

I am about 10 pounds from ideal weight. I am hoping to be able to run a half marthon next July and to continue running as a life long activity. Main goal is to get to below 25% fat and a BMI of around 21 rather than a weight as I keep remembering it's fitness not the figure on the scale that matters.

It's funny, I hated running as a teenager (one older sister and my brother ran quite a bit and tried to get me interested but though I had baseline ability I had no motivation), but now at 38 I actually enjoy it and like improving the distance I can go. ItIt also fits in with my lifestyle. I used to swim a lot but due to access problems (pool hours and cost, needing to be here to send kids to school, job hours) I decided to try running again. I can go out at 6:30 and run 2.5 miles (no in four weeks I can't actually run it all yet - but I can run one mile straight!). I'll have to get out earlier as my distances improve.

On the healthy eating side - I started to record everything I eat when I stared running - I have done this several times in my life and every time I just naturally eat less and lose some weight. When you go to write down a candy bar at 300 calories with 200+ calories from fat, you tend to go why am I eating this and eat an apple or orange at 80 calories instead. Also, I'm much more aware that I am eating too much fat or not enough fiber. It helps our whole family - husband and two kids - eat better too. It's more about remembering to have a good diet than slapping down a quick meal.

Sorry, this ended up a little longer than I expected. It is my first post.
Click to view furseal's profile Expert 56 posts since
Jan 13, 2005
13. Dec 1, 2007 9:53 PM in response to: Guest
I gained 18 pounds and dropped 2 pants sizes.

Worry about how your body looks and feels, not what the scale says.
Click to view halfbyaug's profile Amateur 32 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
14. Dec 1, 2007 11:31 PM in response to: Guest
I can run and not lose weight, I finally joined sparkpeople.com (it's free) and track all my calories there, and I also added in crosstraining (spinning 2 times per week, and weights) and the weight has started to come off. Good luck!