active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
Login to Reply
1 2 Previous Next
Click to view hermama's profile Amateur 25 posts since
Aug 10, 2006

Sep 1, 2007 6:28 AM

walking in running shoes

I have a fairly new pair of Asics 2120 running shoes that haven given me no problems running. I have high arches and supinate. Yesterday, a friend wanted to walk with me, so I put on those shoes and we did a brisk one hour walk. A few hours later and all the the evening, I could hardly walk. It hurt to bend my feet and to let my weight down on my whole foot. I felt like I was balancing on my heels and my toe pads. Now this morning my feet feel like they usually do. Is it a bad idea to walk in running shoes? Or was this just a fluke?
Click to view bigapplepie's profile We're Not Worthy 2,636 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
1. Sep 1, 2007 6:33 AM in response to: hermama
Weird.
Click to view Peptidase1's profile Rookie 1 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
2. Sep 1, 2007 7:10 AM in response to: hermama
No it's not a bad idea to walk in running shoes. Running shoes aren't made based on your pace, or else we'd all have to get different shoes (i.e. 6 min/mi shoes, 8 min/mi shoes, etc.). Some people probably run at your walking pace. I would see if this happens again and then visit your doctor--perhaps to get some inserts.
Click to view kponds's profile Pro 100 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
3. Sep 1, 2007 8:23 AM in response to: hermama
Most (all?) of the hardcore racewalkers train in low-heel shoes like the Asics DS trainer or Brooks ST racer, they seem to abhor high-heeled shoes.

I don't seem to have problems in my regular trainers though, for regular dog-walking purposes.
Click to view maryt091's profile Legend 806 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
4. Sep 1, 2007 8:47 AM in response to: hermama
Your reaction is a little extreme, but I have found that some shoes I can run in for hours give me blisters if I use them for walking even 30 minutes or less. The motion of my foot in the shoe is just different enough walking vs running that they rub in a diferent place. So could be your feet flex differently walking and the rigidity that helps stabilize your running foot may not be that good for your walking stride?
Click to view Nobby063's profile Legend 630 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
5. Sep 1, 2007 12:27 PM in response to: hermama
quote:<HR>Originally posted by maryt:
Your reaction is a little extreme, but I have found that some shoes I can run in for hours give me blisters if I use them for walking even 30 minutes or less. The motion of my foot in the shoe is just different enough walking vs running that they rub in a diferent place. So could be your feet flex differently walking and the rigidity that helps stabilize your running foot may not be that good for your walking stride?<HR>


You see, MaryT, except for the long run for the marathon, we are actually on the same page more often than not! ;o)

In walking, your foot (ore, more accurately, your ankle) flexes more. You DO land on your heel in walking at the highest angle (or, furthest out from the 90 degree from the ground); and you hold on untill the ankle flexes at the deepest angle right before you take off. In other words, I believe (and I'm not a race walker) in race walking, you require more flexible shoes (I mean, you want flexible shoes for running as well). In most cases, I found, you'll get blisters on your heel, wearing running shoes that wouldn't give you blisters on your heel when running (now I'm getting confused what the heck I'm saying...) especially from heel-landing phase.

To actually feel pain seems quite extreme but I had this experience, not in walking but running, when my arch was hurting because the shoe was rigid in the forefoot area. So I cut out a couple of lines of groove so the shoe flexes more; all of a sudden the pain disappeared. Perhaps the similar thing was happening???

At any rate, I personally wouldn't recommend using your expensive running shoes for walking becuase I believe they would wear out differently and breaks down more quickly. I'm not necessarily saying those so-called running shoes or "sneakers" are not designed for walking. But I would have a pair I'd wear just for walking and keep my "favorite" running shoes for running only.
Click to view maryt091's profile Legend 806 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
6. Sep 2, 2007 8:54 AM in response to: hermama
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Nobby:
You see, MaryT, except for the long run for the marathon, we are actually on the same page more often than not! ;o)
.
<HR>

I'm still hoping. Give me time, Nobby and I'll convert you yet!
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Nobby:
In most cases, I found, you'll get blisters on your heel, wearing running shoes that wouldn't give you blisters on your heel when running .<HR>

My experience exactly! I remember one 10K race in particular several years ago where my husband wanted me to walk part of the course with him so he look for good places to photograph (He sometimes races, sometimes does race photography). We walked just past the 1 mile point, and my heel started to feel like it was developing a blister just as I started back. By the time I got back to the start area, one heel was red and itrritated,and the other had developed a full blister. I was not happy. Fortunately, I was able to get a bandaid to protect it from further damage, and running in the shoes was OK because they didn't rub in the same spot, but that's the last time I walked around for a half hour before a race!

As an aside, my husband had an interesting photography session that day as well. He was at a turn where the cars going outbound are separated by a small grassy area from the cars inbound. The first couple of runners followed the police car around the grassy area into the outbound lane, but the rest of the lead pack inadvertently cut the course short and ran in the near lane. Normally not that big a deal (except to my husband because they weren't in the position he thought they were going to be and it wasn't a good photography angle), as they didn't cut the couse short by a lot. However, in this case, it was a certified course with a lot of elite runners and it was first thought John Campbell had a world masters record for the 10K. Unfortunately, after reviewing Mr T's video and pics, and remeasuring the course actually run, it was enough short that it couldn't be certified. The next year, access to that inside lane was blocked off by portable fencing!
Click to view IEatHills4Meals's profile Legend 506 posts since
Nov 21, 2007
7. Sep 2, 2007 9:00 AM in response to: hermama
mmm, I'm not sure of what's causing your pain. But here is my shot. I am a supinator too with high arches, but I am not convinced that this is a specific reason for the pain.
When I power walk or do nordic walking, I feel I put a lot more pressure on my feet to toe of the ground. Different propulsion compared to running, where he motion keeps you more off than on the ground. Excessive pressure causes pain. Sorry if I am saying something stupid. I am playing by ear here.
I agree with the opinion that inserts might help, if you can get some posted on the lateral side, then go from there... I hope you feel better.
Click to view GearGuy081's profile Pro 63 posts since
Jan 15, 2007
8. Sep 2, 2007 10:37 AM in response to: hermama
I frequently see people who have a different gait while walking and running. That's why I watch them walking to get a judge of their gait, put shoes on them, then watch them again.
Click to view dot096's profile Amateur 21 posts since
Apr 27, 2007
9. Sep 2, 2007 11:26 AM in response to: hermama
I always walk in old running shoes if they aren't torn up. Actually I wear them all the time. I don't like ordinary shoes because they aren't that comfortable as running shoes. Running shoes just fit better.
If I choose wrong pair for running I would walk in them.
But I've never had blisters or anything weird like pain.
Click to view kellyl039's profile Rookie 1 posts since
Mar 13, 2005
11. Sep 3, 2007 11:51 PM in response to: hermama
I think you should reevauluate your shoes. Asics 2120's are stability shoes. You should be in cushioned shoes if you supinate, such as asics gel nimbus. Stability shoes will only encourage your foot to supinate more.
Click to view NorthernElf's profile Legend 214 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
13. Sep 4, 2007 9:49 AM in response to: hermama
I second Kellyl - I run in Asics 2110 (2120 is the follow up) because I PRONATE...
Click to view sdewan's profile Expert 53 posts since
Oct 16, 2007
14. Sep 5, 2007 10:33 AM in response to: hermama
I think the key issue is the difference between your walking gait and running gait. For most people these are substantially the same so they can run and walk in the same shoes.

I have extremely high arches and supinate when I walk, but when I run I overpronate. This is because I run with my toes pointed outwards instead of straight ahead. So in my case I need motion control shoes for running, but they just compound my supination if I walk in them.

It also sounds like you may want to investigate some type of orthotic to support your high arches.