active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
17 Replies Last post: Oct 16, 2007 2:43 AM by AKTrail   1 2 Previous Next
Click to view jgrandits's profile Amateur 23 posts since
Jul 29, 2007
Login to Reply

Oct 4, 2007 1:37 PM

Marathon on gatorade only

Hi,
Is gatorade alone sufficient to drink during a marathon or do gels provide better fuel source?
I have run one marathon before, NYC -3:31, and did a gel every six miles, some water in between.
Recently I have been training for NYC or Philly this year and have been doing long runs, 15-20 miles, with only gatorade. Have done two 15 milers without anything to drink, granted it was optimal running weather, low 60's temp.
From a replenishment standpoint does gatorade fit the bill?
Thanks, John
Click to view Harper028's profile Pro 191 posts since
Jan 20, 2007
1. Oct 4, 2007 1:51 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
In general, you need 200-300 calories per hour. This is regardless of season, temperature, humidity etc. Electrolytes needs, however, vary with how much you sweat.

Gatorade Endurance is loaded with sodium and is, in my opinion, a drink more appropriate for hot/humid weather.

Serving Size 8 fl oz.
Calories - 50
Sodium - 200mg
Potassium - 90mg

For me, on hot/humid days, I can take in 40-60 oz of fluid per hour. That would be 250-375 cals per hour, with 1000 mg to 1500 mg of sodium per hour. In other words, 60 oz per hour of Gatorade Endurance would be too much cals and sodium (for me). Even 1000 mg of sodium per hour is a lot. I do OK on 600 mg.

Gels, though, are energy only and do not have electrolytes.

Other sports drinks (Succeed and Hammer products, for example), are more "advanced" than Gatorade. With Succeed, the sports drink doesn't have much electrolyte content and instead you take salt pills every hour or 2.
Click to view lakerunr's profile Pro 151 posts since
Dec 12, 2007
2. Dec 26, 2007 6:41 AM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
Some gels claim to have electrolytes and/or protein, but I prefer GU which is basically carbs. I like Gatorade Endurance, but I can only take so much of it (makes my throat phlegm-up, sorry), so I always alternate with water during a race. On a long training run, I usually start out with G.E. in my bottle the re-fill with water when it's gone. I think it's wise to "top off" your electrolytes before a marathon (supplements, bananas, etc.) as well as hydrating and carbo-loading.

------------------
- Larry -
Boston 2007, 3:53:05
Madison 2007, 3:40:51
Next: Boston Marathon 08
My Profile[/URL" target="_blank">

http://This message has been edited by lstall (edited Oct-04-2007).
Click to view kimber45caliber@yahoo.com's profile Legend 407 posts since
Oct 20, 2007
3. Oct 14, 2007 9:12 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
I have one quick question. I have been looking at Succeed and the S tabs. I have not yet used anything other than water. However my runs are getting longer and I'm running in a remote area. The Succeed looks more beneficial to me than the Gatorade.
I plan on running the HM Miami ING in January. They are using Gatorade Endurance. Should I start using the Gatorade now? Or should I plan on carrying Succeed with me? I am an incredibly slow runner and it will take me at least 3 hours to finish the 1/2. So I'm going to need something other than water. Do other people carry their own sports drink?
Thanks for any suggestions.

Karen
Click to view formationflier's profile Legend 989 posts since
Oct 13, 2007
4. Oct 14, 2007 9:24 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
It all depends on how well trained you are aerobically. I don't take any gels
in marathons and in many cases, I've gone through entire marathons
with few or no calories at all. However, a major focus of my training
involves becoming very efficient at using fat as a significant energy
source.


------------------
MyRunningLog[/URL" target="_blank">
MyStuff[/URL" target="_blank">
Low Heart Rate Training FAQ[/URL" target="_blank">
My marathons and ultras[/URL" target="_blank">
My races and reports[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view LeftRightRepeat's profile Legend 1,618 posts since
Aug 16, 2007
5. Oct 14, 2007 9:28 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
quote:<HR>Originally posted by jgrandits:
Is gatorade alone sufficient to drink during a marathon<HR>


Yes. People, even elites, do marathons all the time with nothing else.

quote:<HR>Originally posted by jgrandits:
do gels provide better fuel source?<HR>


Possibly. Depends on your personal needs and how YOUR body works. Many people benefit from the additional calories. But... You can get the same boost from more Gatorade if you absorb that more easily.

The key is experimentation during training. Find out what works for YOU.


------------------
->>> John[/URL" target="_blank"> <<<-
Go write something in the
Newbie Wiki[/URL" target="_blank">!!
Running Club[/URL" target="_blank"> Tri Club[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view run4262's profile Pro 69 posts since
Jan 12, 2007
6. Oct 14, 2007 9:53 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
I've run my best marathons on gatorade only. Through several years of distance running, I've learned I need to consume around 100 ounces of gatorade during a typical 40-50 degree marathon day. I learned the hard way that I can't mix gatorade and gels--gives me an upset stomach and severe GID, however gels and water work fine.

Bill
Click to view kimber45caliber@yahoo.com's profile Legend 407 posts since
Oct 20, 2007
7. Oct 14, 2007 10:43 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
leitnerj, I read all your posts and value your opinions.
Regarding fat utilization, at a low body fat, what fat is being used for fuel?
This is all new stuff to me, please don't think I'm an idiot. I'm trying to make sense of it all. And I'm certainly not trying to create controversy. My personality is such that I need to make sense of things.
Thanks.
Click to view dave.macluskie's profile Legend 299 posts since
Nov 1, 2007
8. Oct 14, 2007 10:52 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
Kimber -- as I understand it, a pound of fat (what a lovely picture!) contains about 3500 calories. That's about a marathon right there, calorie wise. Even the completely unrealistic 100lb person with 5% body fat would have enough calories. Of course, that's just silly, and you have to take into account all that fat that your body really needs (which I'm sure has some term associated with it), but the point is, even we skinny folks generally contain a lot of calories. Harnessing it is the tough part. That takes training, and I believe what leitnerj is referring to.

Now, I also believe that you don't burn just fat ever. It's always some percentage of sugars and some of fat, with leitnerj probably referring to the fact that he has trained his body to burn a higher percent of fat than say, someone like me, at a given pace or level of effort. See the Maffetone thread and FAQ for more info on that.
Click to view Dana Becker's profile Legend 392 posts since
Nov 20, 2007
9. Dec 26, 2007 6:41 AM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
quote:<HR>Originally posted by kimber45:
leitnerj, I read all your posts and value your opinions.
Regarding fat utilization, at a low body fat, what fat is being used for fuel?
This is all new stuff to me, please don't think I'm an idiot. I'm trying to make sense of it all. And I'm certainly not trying to create controversy. My personality is such that I need to make sense of things.
Thanks.
<HR>


Even at a low body fat, you have glycogen stores sufficient to provide a lot of energy for quite a few miles. Most of these runners have a few things going for them, however. They are experienced, fast, and know what their bodies need to cover the distance they are racing. (and they weigh next to nothing, which lowers their enery requirements)

With regards to mere mortals...I have done up to 23 mile runs with nothing more than 20 ounces of gatorade and electrylyte capsules and water. This was during the summer. During races though, I usually plan on 3 to 4 gels, either Gu or PowerGels.

To get to your point...I wouldn't rely on just Gatorade during the race, unless it is the Endurance formula. If your stomach can handle a few extra gels, then use them.

I know my stomach will handle what I throw at it on race day, so I can cheat during training runs.

During marathons I don't mess around. Even at 190 pounds, I try to consume 300-400 calories worth of gels, and another 300 calories worth of whatever_enhancement_drink is available.

Experiment. We are all an experiment of one.


http://This message has been edited by Docster (edited Oct-14-2007).
Click to view run4262's profile Pro 69 posts since
Jan 12, 2007
10. Oct 14, 2007 11:21 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
Here's a good article that is relevant to the discussion.

http://www.pfitzinger.com/labreports/eatdrink.shtml[/URL" target="_blank">

Bill
Click to view obsessor's profile Legend 488 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
11. Oct 14, 2007 11:33 PM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
in my best marathon so far, I took in plenty of water, 2 gels at about miles 16 and 19, (~200 kcal, total?) and all the water and ultima I could handle. ( 0 kcal in ultima? I did not care much at the time.)

I can't much tell the difference if I take a gell, or use gatorade only, or water only. I go by feel. If I feel hungry - the need for extra calories, I take a gel. # 1 is hydration, then, I think about energy.

Water alone, gatorade alone, or use gel supplements. They can all work, depending upon speed, training, and the individual.
Click to view formationflier's profile Legend 989 posts since
Oct 13, 2007
12. Oct 15, 2007 5:33 AM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
quote:<HR>Originally posted by kimber45:
leitnerj, I read all your posts and value your opinions.
Regarding fat utilization, at a low body fat, what fat is being used for fuel?
This is all new stuff to me, please don't think I'm an idiot. I'm trying to make sense of it all. And I'm certainly not trying to create controversy. My personality is such that I need to make sense of things.
Thanks.
<HR>


I haven't read the posts below yet, but they seem to address
some of the question. First of all, glycogen is always required
no matter what, but you can train yourself to use a higher
percentage of fat than you would otherwise, even at high
intensities. Next, Let's say you weigh 120 lbs and have 5%
body fat (too low, IMHO, for anyone!). That's 6 lbs of fat you
have to draw from. You will not come close to using that up in a
marathon. You will never come close to using 100% fat
as a fuel source in either case, although if you could, you'd
have energy to last a very long time. Good question, not controversial!




------------------
MyRunningLog[/URL" target="_blank">
MyStuff[/URL" target="_blank">
Low Heart Rate Training FAQ[/URL" target="_blank">
My marathons and ultras[/URL" target="_blank">
My races and reports[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view RunnersHigh's profile Legend 259 posts since
Nov 24, 2006
13. Oct 15, 2007 7:28 AM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
I'm going to chime in here because I don't fully understand the fat burning question (my body fat is below 5%). I was always under the impression that fat is more difficult to burn, meaning that the body works harder to burn fat resulting in lower performance if you're not putting in other sources of energy while running a marathon? Wouldn't running an entire marathon while not taking in any carbs be more detrimental to performance? I know that the glycogen stores don't last very long but I thought that was the reason why you had to take in other carbs during the marathon? Again, I'm new to this and have been trying to take some of this in. Are there any studies that suggest that burning fat is easier on the body when discussing performance?
Click to view dg12002's profile Legend 622 posts since
Aug 26, 2003
14. Oct 15, 2007 9:51 AM in response to: jgrandits
Re: Marathon on gatorade only
I mix things up myself. Gatorade every other station till around halfway. Then I do a gel and water 3 times every other station afterward then Gatorade til finish.

This gives me something in my tummy.