active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
648 Replies Last post: Dec 12, 2007 12:59 PM by Guest   Go to original post 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 ... 44 Previous Next
Click to view dgb2n's profile Pro 139 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
60. Oct 23, 2007 4:17 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
Roster,

I believe that there are a number of ways to approach low heart rate training, even at what should be the right target heart rate. It might be worth comparing a couple of methods and see where that puts you.

Parker uses 70% of your working heart rate as the ceiling for easy runs (Karvonen method). For me, that works out to
52 + .7*(185-52)=145.1

I'm 41 years old so this tracks pretty close to my MAF (139+5=144). For you, it might not but it may still let you make meaningful progress and not have to walk all the time. might be worth trying to measure your max (220-age is an estimate that is often off of the actual) and calculate a 70% threshold.

I've been working Parker's method to varying degrees of success over the last few years. Quite a bit of progress lately. Here's my results from today's 8 mile run:
9:31, 135bpm
9:22, 140bpm
9:24, 141bpm
9:34, 142bpm
9:18, 144bpm (mostly into the wind)
9:18, 142bpm
9:24, 144bpm
9:37, 144bpm (mostly into the wind)
9:54, 148bpm (last bit)

I'm not as strict as most on this board but this does represent about a minute faster per mile (or more) than when I first started low heart rate training.

All I'm saying is calculate it a couple of ways and see if perhaps you could shoot towards a higher number. You may not progress as quickly but at least you'll have your sanity

------------------
My Running Log[/URL" target="_blank">

My User Profile[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view Johnnie031's profile Amateur 18 posts since
May 18, 2007
61. Oct 23, 2007 4:20 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
Following is my race report from Indianapolis Marathon Oct. 20 (my first). I am going to attempt the aerobic base building detailed on this thread. It makes sense to me. Just wanted to say hello and thanks for the info!!

Race report...

YEEEAAAHHHH! What a beautiful, perfect day for a run. Weather: 50-60 degrees, pleasant breeze, sunshine, beautiful fall foilage. I would not change a single thing about the enviornment.

Lining up, I was plain giddy. So much excited energy surging through every part of me. My husband was laughing at my childlike glee. I met Courtney at the start line, while impatiently awaiting the announcer to hush and let us run. She was running the half, but had run her first marathon the year before, same course. She is the same age as me, and like all of us over-zealous female runners, she too had hoped to qualify for Boston at her first marathon. Her piece of advice for me; don't spend all your cash up front. Well, I failed to heed her warning. I was so rested from tapering, and thrilled beyond belief to finally be at the starting line, that at the sound of the gun I was a wind up toy in contact with a surface at last. I was at the half way point by 1:40, well on my way to Boston by my calculations.

Then it happened, the dreaded, legendary wall. When? Maybe mile 16, when it occurred to me that I still had over 10 miles remaining, and my quads were in denial of this fact. By mile 18, I decided I would walk and I was about to stop, when a spectator informed me she was following her husband and inadvertently me as well. She told me I was an inspiration and I knew then that I had to keep running. I did not walk once the entire 26.2 miles, not even at water stations, which is a new feat for me.
I did take my ipod, which I had considered not doing, and I am grateful that I did (thank you Cheri). There were times when I felt I was running by myself, the participants seeming few and far between.
Miles 20-25 were particularly difficult and my pace dropped immensely. I was doing 7 min miles for some time in the beginning, and 9:30 by the end. This large discrepancy tells me my aerobic base needs work (new obsession in the works - MAF maffetone training). I ran so fast to start, that my body could not keep up with the lactic acid load I created, hence the uncooperative leg musculature later on. I know it wasn't an issue of lacking carbo load. I ate more pasta over the past week then in my entire life! I was diligent about staying hydrated as well.
25 to the finish was easier b/c of the mental relief of that came with knowing there was just one more mile. And the tears came with a vengence. I thought I had dodged them. That I was just one of those runners who didn't cry during the race. Nope. I had done it. A goal I never thought I would reach. I now belonged to a tiny segment of the population who have run 26.2 consecutive miles. I thought of the wonderful people who have come into my life as a direct result of my training. I thought of getting to talk to Cheri for the first time the day before the race. Just as I suspected, she is a sweetheart! Of John and I sharing this experience together, and how far he has come in the past 6 months. Of getting to know myself mentally and physically beyond my imagination. Of Mary waiting to greet me at the finish. Of John Blais, warrior poet completing an iron man in the face of ALS. Of Lara's kind soul and encouragement. Of old dreams released and new ones realized. I crossed that longed for finish line, tears streaming, smiling from the inside out, aching in places I had never physically sensed, thanking God for life. Mary and I waited. Then came John. I was equally excited for his finish. A marathon after 1.5 years of running!! I jumped back in and ran across behind him because I could wait no longer to kiss his salt streaked face and thank him for the multitude of ways in which he enhances my life.
3 hours 44 minutes and 38 seconds! Just 4 minutes from Boston. No problem. Something tells me this is the first of many.
Click to view DavidD063's profile Legend 361 posts since
Jan 25, 2007
62. Oct 23, 2007 4:56 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
I don?t put much into one?s max heart rate. For one thing, it?s always an estimation, whether calculated (as in 220 minus age) or obtained during an ?all out? effort. (I tried instigating a discussion on this way back when I asked ?what does caffeine do to the max HR.?)

The 180 formula (180 minus age with the various adjustments) has nothing to do with max HR. According to Maffetone, the formula is a means to an end (when asked about the significance of the 180 he said it came to him in the shower). Specifically, the 180 formula, when used correctly, correlates well with a treadmill test. That?s not to say it?s perfect or fits everyone well. But in my experience, the vast majority of treadmill tests fall within a couple of beats of the 180 formula.

As I?ve stated here numerous times, many people don?t use the formula correctly. Adding 5 because you live in Nebraska is not valid reason for a higher max aerobic HR. Or adding 10 because you?re over 65 years.

I always recommend a person get a treadmill test if it?s available, if it?s performed properly and if someone explains the results to you. Lots of ?if?s? there, and considering it may cost a few hundred dollars, it might be best for most people to be honest with the 180 formula and see how things work out in a month by monitoring yourself (such as with an MAF test).
Click to view dfcameron's profile Pro 122 posts since
Apr 5, 2007
63. Oct 23, 2007 5:45 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Johnnie:
Following is my race report from Indianapolis Marathon Oct. 20 (my first). I am going to attempt the aerobic base building detailed on this thread. It makes sense to me. Just wanted to say hello and thanks for the info!!

Race report...

YEEEAAAHHHH! What a beautiful, perfect day for a run. Weather: 50-60 degrees, pleasant breeze, sunshine, beautiful fall foilage. I would not change a single thing about the enviornment.

Lining up, I was plain giddy. So much excited energy surging through every part of me. My husband was laughing at my childlike glee. I met Courtney at the start line, while impatiently awaiting the announcer to hush and let us run. She was running the half, but had run her first marathon the year before, same course. She is the same age as me, and like all of us over-zealous female runners, she too had hoped to qualify for Boston at her first marathon. Her piece of advice for me; don't spend all your cash up front. Well, I failed to heed her warning. I was so rested from tapering, and thrilled beyond belief to finally be at the starting line, that at the sound of the gun I was a wind up toy in contact with a surface at last. I was at the half way point by 1:40, well on my way to Boston by my calculations.

Then it happened, the dreaded, legendary wall. When? Maybe mile 16, when it occurred to me that I still had over 10 miles remaining, and my quads were in denial of this fact. By mile 18, I decided I would walk and I was about to stop, when a spectator informed me she was following her husband and inadvertently me as well. She told me I was an inspiration and I knew then that I had to keep running. I did not walk once the entire 26.2 miles, not even at water stations, which is a new feat for me.
I did take my ipod, which I had considered not doing, and I am grateful that I did (thank you Cheri). There were times when I felt I was running by myself, the participants seeming few and far between.
Miles 20-25 were particularly difficult and my pace dropped immensely. I was doing 7 min miles for some time in the beginning, and 9:30 by the end. This large discrepancy tells me my aerobic base needs work (new obsession in the works - MAF maffetone training). I ran so fast to start, that my body could not keep up with the lactic acid load I created, hence the uncooperative leg musculature later on. I know it wasn't an issue of lacking carbo load. I ate more pasta over the past week then in my entire life! I was diligent about staying hydrated as well.
25 to the finish was easier b/c of the mental relief of that came with knowing there was just one more mile. And the tears came with a vengence. I thought I had dodged them. That I was just one of those runners who didn't cry during the race. Nope. I had done it. A goal I never thought I would reach. I now belonged to a tiny segment of the population who have run 26.2 consecutive miles. I thought of the wonderful people who have come into my life as a direct result of my training. I thought of getting to talk to Cheri for the first time the day before the race. Just as I suspected, she is a sweetheart! Of John and I sharing this experience together, and how far he has come in the past 6 months. Of getting to know myself mentally and physically beyond my imagination. Of Mary waiting to greet me at the finish. Of John Blais, warrior poet completing an iron man in the face of ALS. Of Lara's kind soul and encouragement. Of old dreams released and new ones realized. I crossed that longed for finish line, tears streaming, smiling from the inside out, aching in places I had never physically sensed, thanking God for life. Mary and I waited. Then came John. I was equally excited for his finish. A marathon after 1.5 years of running!! I jumped back in and ran across behind him because I could wait no longer to kiss his salt streaked face and thank him for the multitude of ways in which he enhances my life.
3 hours 44 minutes and 38 seconds! Just 4 minutes from Boston. No problem. Something tells me this is the first of many.
<HR>



Congratulations on the run either way. I believe by building the aerobic base, you can avoid the wall. I did it for Detroit on Sunday (Oct 21); my report is a little earlier in here. Great training method. Glad you're taking this all as a big positive; and ready to move to the next phase.
Click to view dfcameron's profile Pro 122 posts since
Apr 5, 2007
64. Oct 23, 2007 5:48 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Diesel88:
I have been enjoying this method of training for a few months now. I am enjoying the absence of the aches and pains that my previous running schedule would incur even though I am running for longer periods of time than ever before.

I want to take this to the next level and start endurance running early next year (50 milers ). I know this current method of training depends less on carbs as fuel and more on fat, allowing one to go longer and farther. With this said, should I be looking at increasing my fat intake to store the fuel necessary to accomodate the extended hours on the road in the coming months? And by how much?

I currently bring carbs in, but mostly in the form of beans, rice, and not so much pasta and bread. Should I decrease carbs now since they are not used as much of a fuel source or keep them as part of my diet?

Many thanks. I would post this in CC but there is so much misinformation in there...(no pressure!)

<HR>


I've done 3 50-milers, and haven't really changed my eating. The body can store quite a bit of usable fat. What changes is that your muscles have a way of either storing or accessing it through long, long training runs. When I did my first 20 mile run, it took 3 hours and 40 minutes (which is slow for me) because I really slowed after a ran out of glycogen, I think. By the 4th run, I was doing those runs in 3:05 or so, because I could sustain pace all the way through. In training for 50 milers, I've used 50Ks as training runs and gone up to 6
hours on trails and sustained a good pace as long as I've trained my body to burn fat. I do run these 50K at a lower heart rate than even MAF for most of them - maxing out at MAF.

Just eat right.
Click to view jjwaverly42's profile Legend 337 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
66. Oct 23, 2007 10:51 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by roster:
quote:Yes, I'm sure that's true - but I'd still value advice about (1) does my MAF sound right, or too low; and (2) should I just be walking, or trying to run very slowly and/or downhill at times.

<HR>


You previously posted that your MAF was 108 (180-57=123-15 for injury and medication). I suggested a bump to 113 for being 57.

According to MAF training, it sounds right. It's entirely up to you what you choose to do. Perhaps your medication is not an issue. Perhaps your injury isn't one. You could ignore the subtractions and use 123, 128, or whatever. It's all a matter of honest self-assessment, monitoring of stress through MAF tests, what you are trying to accomplish and what you are willing to go through to do so.

Walking is not uncommon. I've had to walk on occasion to stay under.
No biggie. Just part of the journey to Boston.

Running downhill all the time is probably not a good idea for anyone.

Keep going!

--Jimmy

MAF log[/URL" target="_blank">

profile[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view jjwaverly42's profile Legend 337 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
67. Dec 26, 2007 7:01 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
On walking. I actually have inserted walks into my training. I've come to enjoy them, and it helps in developing slow twitch fibers.

--Jimmy

MAF log[/URL" target="_blank">
zzzzzzz[/URL" target="_blank">

http://This message has been edited by jjwaverly42 (edited Oct-23-2007).
Click to view bluelake's profile Pro 66 posts since
Oct 25, 2007
68. Oct 24, 2007 9:19 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
I started MAF training @ 20-25 mpw for about 12 weeks, then added in some races for speedwork. I initially didn't take the -10 beats for my BP medication (guess I was in denial.) I have gone back to aerobic basebuilding for a while, and increased to 30+ mpw but would like a way to measure my progress. Any suggestions on the MAF tests? Maffetone recommends you do them under the same conditions, but I run outdoors. I can't control the temp and humidity. I thought my race times would be a good indication of my progress, but haven't seen much improvement.

------------------
bluelake "It's not easy, but it's worth it"See[/URL" target="_blank"> My Profile! URL
Click to view streeetch's profile Amateur 27 posts since
Sep 16, 2006
69. Oct 24, 2007 9:59 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by bluelake:
I started MAF training @ 20-25 mpw for about 12 weeks, then added in some races for speedwork. I initially didn't take the -10 beats for my BP medication (guess I was in denial.) I have gone back to aerobic basebuilding for a while, and increased to 30+ mpw but would like a way to measure my progress. Any suggestions on the MAF tests? Maffetone recommends you do them under the same conditions, but I run outdoors. I can't control the temp and humidity. I thought my race times would be a good indication of my progress, but haven't seen much improvement.

<HR>


I use my logbook to track progress. I note start and finish temp and dew point, distance, average and max HR, and HR at 1 mile splits. Prior to getting a Garmin I drove my running routes to find out the mile points. I've been doing this for the past 7 months, the most noticeable improvement has been in the ability to control my HR under all circumstances (uphill, downhill, heat, longer runs). Increased speed shows up after that.

------------------
stretch[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view Bigdave10000's profile Pro 87 posts since
Oct 22, 2007
70. Oct 24, 2007 10:04 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
Thanks Jesse and Jimmy for posting these threads. I have been reading them for years. I haven't used the Maffetone training but have just been doing low HR easy pace running for years. In early 2004 I was running about 20-25 MPW. The problem was (didn't know it at the time) I was running at MP+ effort all the time. I bought a HR monitor, slowed down, and got my mileage up to about 65-70 MPW. In two years my half marathon PR went from 1:47 to 1:33.

After that I had heart problems. 40 years old with 7 blockages. Had 5 stents put in and took 6 months off.

I think with low HR training you need to have some basic running fitness before starting. Otherwise you HR shoots up at really slow speeds.

I started over again this past May. My HR max is 185. Here is my progress since May.

HR Avg AVG PACE Miles for the month
147 9:21 98 May
144 9:13 146 June
141 9:11 210 July
140 8:44 286 Aug
138 8:37 291 Sept
139 8:32 207 Oct so far

When I set my 5k PR of 18:51 my avg HR was 139 and avg pace was 8:19 for the month. So I am not to far away.

I don't think you need a HR monitor. The key is to slow down enough so you can increase your mileage without getting hurt. That being said, I needed to run with a HR monitor get get the feedback on my effort so that I would slow down enough.

I have over 8000 miles or HR and pace data. It is one of ways I picked up that I was have Heart problems. My HR started going up and my pace started slowing down. I was getting shortness of breath so I went to the Doctor.

Call it low HR training or Base building, I just wanted to say that it does work.



------------------
My Profile[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view jjwaverly42's profile Legend 337 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
71. Oct 24, 2007 10:27 AM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
Glad you caught the problem before it dropped you, Dave. One of the plusses of a HRM. If you're getting worse and worse at the same HR, it indicates some kind of stress going on in the body. It can tell you when to back off, and in your case, it might be time fo a check-up. I'll remember your post if I ever see huge drops. Thanks for checking in (and not checking out!) and posting.

I wish you a long life of health and clear arteries from here on in.

Keep going!

--Jimmy

MAF log[/URL" target="_blank">
zzzzzzz[/URL" target="_blank">[/B][/QUOTE]
Click to view runawayjesse's profile Legend 538 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
72. Oct 24, 2007 2:11 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
Jesse, forgive me if this was covered and I'm sure it was but can you relate a heart rate with marathon effort based on a person's MAFF HR? Like Maff + 20 or something? Generally people wil race a marathon btw 80-85% max heart rate but for those who follow MAFF rather than a % of max heart rate is their a safe guideline?
Click to view aharmer's profile Legend 460 posts since
May 25, 2005
74. Oct 24, 2007 6:37 PM in response to: formationflier
Re: Basebuilding, low heart rate training, via Maffetone, Mark Allen, Hadd, Mittleman
quote:<HR>Originally posted by bigdave10000:
Thanks Jesse and Jimmy for posting these threads. I have been reading them for years. I haven't used the Maffetone training but have just been doing low HR easy pace running for years. In early 2004 I was running about 20-25 MPW. The problem was (didn't know it at the time) I was running at MP+ effort all the time. I bought a HR monitor, slowed down, and got my mileage up to about 65-70 MPW. In two years my half marathon PR went from 1:47 to 1:33.

After that I had heart problems. 40 years old with 7 blockages. Had 5 stents put in and took 6 months off.

I think with low HR training you need to have some basic running fitness before starting. Otherwise you HR shoots up at really slow speeds.

I started over again this past May. My HR max is 185. Here is my progress since May.

HR Avg AVG PACE Miles for the month
147 9:21 98 May
144 9:13 146 June
141 9:11 210 July
140 8:44 286 Aug
138 8:37 291 Sept
139 8:32 207 Oct so far

When I set my 5k PR of 18:51 my avg HR was 139 and avg pace was 8:19 for the month. So I am not to far away.

I don't think you need a HR monitor. The key is to slow down enough so you can increase your mileage without getting hurt. That being said, I needed to run with a HR monitor get get the feedback on my effort so that I would slow down enough.

I have over 8000 miles or HR and pace data. It is one of ways I picked up that I was have Heart problems. My HR started going up and my pace started slowing down. I was getting shortness of breath so I went to the Doctor.

Call it low HR training or Base building, I just wanted to say that it does work.

<HR>


Big Dave,
Awesome message, great to hear you're feeling so well. I'm familiar with your situation (not yours personally) because I sell the stents, balloons, etc. that the docs use during the procedure. You've made great progress, looking forward to more updates!

------------------
My Profile[/URL" target="_blank">

"Pain is temporary. Regret hurts forever."
www.analytical-training.blogspot.com