active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
11 Replies Last post: Jul 1, 2006 6:07 PM by paulmitch  
Click to view NickPousson's profile Rookie 4 posts since
Oct 28, 2005
Login to Reply

Jun 21, 2006 9:10 AM

Marathon Strategy

Im soon enough going to be tackling a marathon and would like some feedback on what ratios and speeds people have used with success. Im aiming for a sub 4:18 in order to qualify for an ultra early in the new year. If anyone has finished close to this time PLEASE let me know your valuable info.
Click to view GaRebelRunner075's profile Pro 147 posts since
Apr 13, 2003
1. Jun 25, 2006 3:38 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
A couple of years ago a lady I helped train with Galloway and I ran the Chickamauga marathon using a 6/1 ratio. We trained for the marathon with the 10:30 group on our Sunday runs. She dropped the walk breaks at mile 20 and finished in 3:55. I continued with them and finished in 4:10.
Click to view Nash131's profile Rookie 4 posts since
Jul 1, 2006
2. Jun 27, 2006 9:05 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
Hi Nick. Jeff, as recent as a year ago, revised his recommended run/walk ratios incorporating more walk breaks. He's seen great results in his training groups. I know several people that have cut back to 2/1 or 3/1 ratios and are posting PR's!
Click to view GaRebelRunner075's profile Pro 147 posts since
Apr 13, 2003
3. Jun 28, 2006 7:33 AM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
I have not met anyone using 2/1 and/or 3/1 who went under 4 hours. Which isn't to say it can't or has'nt been done. But the speed between those 1 minute walks would have to pretty decent.
Click to view bullheads's profile Pro 61 posts since
Jun 5, 2006
4. Jun 28, 2006 1:05 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
quote:<HR>Originally posted by GaRebelRunner:
I have not met anyone using 2/1 and/or 3/1 who went under 4 hours. Which isn't to say it can't or has'nt been done. But the speed between those 1 minute walks would have to pretty decent.<HR>


I haven't gone under 4 hours with 3-1, but I have run 4:11
at 3-1. I think a person could get very close to 4:00 flat
at 3-1, not sure about sub 4 hr.
Click to view Forestina Gump's profile Pro 84 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
5. Jun 28, 2006 8:56 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
Hi Nick,

I was training for my 1st Marathon recently I will honestly say that having to run Time Ratio's of 2/1's and 3/1's seemed very constrictive. I didn't like them! Especially If your a person that really want's to be able to Run enough to know that you accomplished some distances during your run.

I have been using the Run/walk Ratio's for a couple of years and have found that I could get the same results using 5/1's or 10/1's But after awhile if you use any kind of timer watch, you may find your self tied to the Bells and chimes to tell you went to run and when to walk? Can you get any kind of enjoyment out of your Long Run or Race?

So I have switched to using more of a Distance Ratio I could set my Garmin to a certain distances of either 1/2 mile, 1 mile, 1 1/2 miles and or 2 miles. Because I read that most Marathon will place their water/aid stations at about 1 1/2 miles to 2 miles.

But recently I have felt more "Freedom" to choose my own Distance on my Routes. I run to land marks such as houses, or a specfic street. I know the approx distance from previous messured Runs. But I find that is more Fun to Run when I don't have some Blasted Beeper telling me what to do!

True, if your a "very" fast Runner to be able to Run fast during the 2 minute Run segment that's Great! But if you a very slow runner like me I think that the 2/1 ratios would slow me down with more fustrations of not getting anywhere than any over all improvement.

But that's all my 2 cents worth... it's really up to what you want to do?

Forestina
Click to view bullheads's profile Pro 61 posts since
Jun 5, 2006
7. Jun 29, 2006 5:37 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
quote:<HR>Originally posted by Forestina Gump:
Hi Nick,

I was training for my 1st Marathon recently I will honestly say that having to run Time Ratio's of 2/1's and 3/1's seemed very constrictive. I didn't like them! Especially If your a person that really want's to be able to Run enough to know that you accomplished some distances during your run.

I have been using the Run/walk Ratio's for a couple of years and have found that I could get the same results using 5/1's or 10/1's But after awhile if you use any kind of timer watch, you may find your self tied to the Bells and chimes to tell you went to run and when to walk? Can you get any kind of enjoyment out of your Long Run or Race?

So I have switched to using more of a Distance Ratio I could set my Garmin to a certain distances of either 1/2 mile, 1 mile, 1 1/2 miles and or 2 miles. Because I read that most Marathon will place their water/aid stations at about 1 1/2 miles to 2 miles.

But recently I have felt more "Freedom" to choose my own Distance on my Routes. I run to land marks such as houses, or a specfic street. I know the approx distance from previous messured Runs. But I find that is more Fun to Run when I don't have some Blasted Beeper telling me what to do!

True, if your a "very" fast Runner to be able to Run fast during the 2 minute Run segment that's Great! But if you a very slow runner like me I think that the 2/1 ratios would slow me down with more fustrations of not getting anywhere than any over all improvement.

But that's all my 2 cents worth... it's really up to what you want to do?

Forestina
<HR>
Dear Forestina

You may find that your watch and beeper are your best
friends at mile 21. You will be able to break the distance down into managable segments when fatigue creeps in.
The watch and beep will give you a psychological edge
in the later miles. You will find that your marathon is
more enjoyable. That is just my opinion after running 15
marathons the last 3 years. I ran slower at 5-1 and 8-1
than 3-1. In relative terms I am no speed demon. Jeff
advised me to use the shorter intervals at his running school and shorter intervals have improved my marathon times by
40 minutes. Good luck in your marathon.
e-coaching.
Click to view Forestina Gump's profile Pro 84 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
8. Dec 27, 2007 3:26 AM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
Dear bullheads,

Unfortunately I dropped the ecoaching with Jeff...and got a refund. I felt that I could not get across to him how I felt about my Running. That I didn't like doing the short Run/walk ratio's of 2/1 or 3 / 1's . I hated doing them!!!! I had alot of trouble running slower, I know it's all suppose to be injury free But for me running anything slower than a 12 minute mile pace...I felt alot more pain and jaring in my knees and hips that I do when I run a 10 minute pace because I felt lighter on my feet at a 9 or 10 minute pace. I could not get that accoss? Plus! I can not keep my feet too low to the ground with out tripping and stubbling over a rock or crack in the sidewalk or street or on a uneaven dirt trail! In trying to keep my feet low to the ground I actually tripped and fell back in January and cracked 2 ribs did he listen or care...NO!

Coaching by email/internet isn't always the best solution in getting good guidence because They do no know you that well for one thing. Nor can see how your actually running to help you? He wasn't open minded enough for me to be able to share any of my suggestions that I felt worked better with my Capibilites either!

Ofcourse I could not afford to go to any of the Running Schools with Gas / airline prices these days... I had barely enough to try the ecoaching (but I got that back) and just enough saved that paid my Marathon registration entry and for my Hotel. After that I'm broke!

forestina

http://This message has been edited by Forestina Gump (edited Jul-01-2006).
Click to view bullheads's profile Pro 61 posts since
Jun 5, 2006
9. Jul 1, 2006 2:13 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
Dear Forestina

Sounds like the Garmin may be the way to go. Maybe
you should set it at 1/2 mile and take walk breaks every
half mile. I'd just run using my natural gate and not
get too hung up on form. I wouldn't even keep track
of my pace. Just run what feels natural. Try to run
so you can hold a conversation with your training partner.
I run by myself, so I try talking to myself. People think I am
crazy, but it works. How far are you going on your long runs at this point? When is your marathon? I am sure you will
be fine and do great on your first marathon. Sometimes
when I am tired on a long 20 mile training run, I stop
off the side of the road and visit with someone for a bit
in their front yard. This gives me an extra rest. I
have run some of my best long runs after shooting the bull
with some one. Good luck on your marathon!
Click to view Forestina Gump's profile Pro 84 posts since
Dec 14, 2007
10. Dec 27, 2007 3:26 AM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
Hi bullheads,

Yes, I'm thinking of doing the sets of 1/2 miles and takeing my walk breaks every half mile. I agree, running using my natural gate and pace I feel a lot more comfortable for sure.
I too run a lot by myself too, I try run where I breath easily and normally as possible (not gasping for air) where I can take in some deep breaths of air. and that is about a 10-12 minute pace range.

Currently I'm following Hal Higdon's Novice Plan, (he does alow Walkbreaks and encourages them but not as strickly as Galloway) I Just finished the second week Today with a 7 mile Long Run. Next week it drops to 5 then after that each weekend's LR's are 9,10, 7, 12, 13, 10, 15 16, 12, 18, 14, 20, 12, 8 Rest and Marathon Race. I'm kind of glad that it only go's up to 20 miles? some of Galloway's plans go way up to 28+ miles... I don't think I would have made it and it probably would have taken me most of the Day just to do 28 whew!


I will be training with my Local Running Club with Groups. We start next weekend with the 5 mile Long Run. My First Marathon Race will Be Chicago on Oct 22nd.

Forestina

http://This message has been edited by Forestina Gump (edited Jul-01-2006).
Click to view paulmitch's profile Legend 308 posts since
Jul 9, 2007
11. Jul 1, 2006 6:07 PM in response to: NickPousson
Re: Marathon Strategy
It's kind of funny because both marathons I was a part of I thought I had a strategy and both sucked. So I talked to a marathoner one night who is the head of my club. I bought a heart rate monitor, and now I am running long runs based on my Hr not so much pace. Although they both coincide sort of speak for me. He said whatever your goal 3:30 or 3:15 which is mine stick to it. He did it in 3:07 and said that he went into like the 16-17th mile and felt great, and started going crazy like high 6's splits.Then he slowed down and realized STICK WITH THE PLAN. That is where I made my mistake. You feel good, and go away from your plan. Find a plan, find out what pace you need to implement it, and do not ever deviate from it, no matter how good you feel.