84 Replies
Last post:
Feb 24, 2008 4:57 PM by
Jimmy D Jarhead
2,402 posts since Aug 21, 2007
Feb 24, 2008 5:22 PM
The Department of Defense Thread
My son just got a letter from the Defense Department saying he was ineligible for military service because of his ADD. He has taken ADD medications off and on to help him stay focused at school/work, but not reguarly. And he has never been tested for, nor official diagnosed (that I know of) with ADD, and his current doctor wrote them a note saying he was fine without medication and had no problems. The Army is allowing those with a felony on their record to join the military right now.. But my son isn't fit for service because he once took Adderall, even though he made a 97 on his ASVAB (if you make over 92, you can get into the space program apparently)???
WTF????????? He's devastated and our military just lost a brilliant mind. The world is insane...
Sorry, I just really needed to vent. If you have anything mean to say, please just don't reply. I'll just start crying.
Look, Active finally added signature lines!
1,515 posts since Aug 15, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Nita... as an ADHD researcher, I've sadly heard horror stories like this before. In fact, a MAJOR player in the field of ADHD's son had the same thing happen. I was told that the reason they gave was that if you need meds to focus and there is a problem getting the kid meds then they'll have ADHD symptoms at times when they need to focus and function at maximum capacity. That reason seems ridiculous to me, because then anyone who needs any type of meds shouldn't be serving. If your son's never been tested, would it be worth getting tested to prove he's not ADHD? It's actually rather hard to meet full diagnostic criteria, especially in adulthood. I'm so sorry... let me know if I can help with referrals, suggestions, info, etc.
In Training:
Marine Corps Marathon 2008; Antarctica Marathon 2009; Pittsburgh Marathon 2009; http://community.active.com/blogs/KatRunsAntarctica
2,402 posts since Aug 21, 2007
2.
Feb 20, 2008 2:21 PM

in response to: DCtoPgh
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Thanks, Kat. I may seriously suggest that, getting tested to prove that he's NOT. If I knew who to call to get tested... Any clue in the Dallas area? And what are the chances the Dept. of Defense would ever even give a **** or look at them? Probably none.
My husband just retired last year as an E-8. I think he's thinking he has some friends he can call, but I don't think that's going to have any influence in this situation.
He was so excited about finally having a plan to succeed, was so pumped up about the Air Force. It's just insane that they would not let him in. He's seriously in shock. They had told him at his physical that it was waived all the time, just to send his records over from his doctor's office and they would call him back to talk to him. Which his records all said that he had no problem, was healthy as a horse, fine without medication. Not sure what they wanted the records for... They didn't even call him, just sent him a form letter. A$$holes.
I'm expecting the FBI at my door any second now. Maybe Dave will delete my post to keep me out of trouble.
Argh. I can't work now. The military has ruined my day/week/month/year once again.
Look, Active finally added signature lines!
2,055 posts since Jan 19, 2008
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Sometime these big outfits are like dinosaures, the head doesn't know what the tail is doing. So sorry to hear this Nita.
2,402 posts since Aug 21, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
So true. Thanks, Omi.
Look, Active finally added signature lines!
2,359 posts since Nov 19, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Hey Nita, I'm really sorry to hear about that. Not to put my own dirty laundry out there, but I actually had this happen to me back in 97 or 98. I can't remember which any more. I had my bag packed and everything. I was actually sitting at the Meps office waiting to go to Basic Training. And suddenly they got the word that it wasn't waived and I was put on a bus and sent back home. I cried the whole way home on the bus. Looking back now, it was a blessing. Since then the Department of Defense has reevaluated their position on me, but I'm sad that it is still happening. I had all the Doctors records and letters from my doctor as well. Saying I was fine without medication. I'm not sure what that part of the process was about. I don't know if it helps to know that he wasn't the only one. And I also had very high ASVAB scores with perfect scores in Physics. LOL. So I don't know what they want. I guess they just want liars who cover that stuff up in order to get what they want. Which is EXACTLY what I was told to do by my recruiter. And if I had, I probably would have a completely different life now. maybe you can have him figure out what he really likes to do and figure out careers that allign with that. Then maybe he can apply for entry positions at companies that offer those positions. Then he can have them pay for school as he moves up. Just a thought. Its what I did. And I ended up owning my own car at 21 and my own house at 24. It may be a blessing for him as well. I'm not saying don't try other methods of getting him in, like the testing and such. If you can thats great. Perhaps I could have tried harder back in the day. If I can do anything, let me know.
1,515 posts since Aug 15, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Nita- I lost your e-mail, so I PMed you.
In Training:
Marine Corps Marathon 2008; Antarctica Marathon 2009; Pittsburgh Marathon 2009; http://community.active.com/blogs/KatRunsAntarctica
7 posts since Feb 20, 2008
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Nita, I share with you your thoughts and experiences. I was prescribed Nexium for acid-reflux, although I was never diagnosed "officially" (by endoscopy, PH test or Barium x-rays, EGD, etc...) as having acid-reflux. BUT, I was popping pills although I was never diagnosed. Like other posts/comments, I suggest your son not to disclose anything that is not officially on ANY records. Secondly, the recruiters and the MedCom/MEPS is not going to investigate your kid's civilian medical records. At worst they'll pop a champagne bottle celebrating their recruits quota achievement. I was a former Marine Recon 89-93 and wanted to re-enlist in 2005. I called the local Marines recruiting station and they gave me all kinds of run around, because I disclosed the fact that I was popping Nexium. A year passed and nothing, so I went to Army National Guard recruiters and I was sworn in 2 months later (without disclosing that I take occasionally Nexium). Hey...! if they don't mind my burpings every now and then...all is good. The rule is, once he is in, they will prescibe him whatever he needs to perform at his best. Let them figure it out on the back end, rather than the front end and penalize his chances to serve. Tell your son to visit another recruiting station in 6 months or so, gives him time to be in top physical condition and mental preparedness, and when filling out the less-than-tree-hugging paperwork not to disclose ANYTHING that has not been diagnosed by a professional. Essentially, you/he is not lying, simply not telling everything they don't need to know. If he sucks his thumb at night, don't say anything...it wasn't diagnosed. Your son will be a Great soldier one day, I believe. Good Luck!
2,402 posts since Aug 21, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
NE-Xamax, that's funn you said that. His recruiter told him not to mention it. Then when they got there, to MEPS, of course they gave him the "if your recruiter told you to lie about anything, we will find out and you will go to jail" speech, so my son 'fessed up, like a good (albeit naive) boy... So true, they just want effing liars and criminals, it seems. It's just so freaking outrageous.
So if he goes again in a few months to another recrutiing station/another MEPS, they won't have the record of him being rejected now? That's hard to believe!
Holly, that's just amazing, you went through the same thing! Thank you so much for sharing, both you guys. You know how misery loves company. We'll see if we can get around this block. If not, we'll try again somewhere else in a few months, as suggested. If not, well, he's still brilliant and has a great future ahead of him. And the U.S. Air Force missed out. That's sad.
Kat, got your PM. Thank you SO MUCH. Great info, just what we needed. I guess we'll go from here and see where it takes us.
Nita
P.S. Thanks for being my therapy board
No, no, I wasn't in therapy! Don't tell the military!
Look, Active finally added signature lines!
7 posts since Feb 20, 2008
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
I know it's hard to believe that they won't find out, but they process so many recruits (1000s) every month, there is no way they can track the previous entries and/or attempts. As they say: "the fish stinks from the head"... Look when I joined in '89 I was told that I couldn't join the military intelligence (MI) because my family lives abroad. National Security issues...yadiyada... I joined my Marine unit and suddenly the MI Officer-in-Charge notices my foreign accent (I speak 5 languages). The next thing I know I am transitioned into an MI unit (from Admin) supporting the Recon units with a Top Secret clearance...! All the rules and regulations implied when being recruited went out the door the moment I became a Marine on that Parade deck. I am nearly 40, soon going to go to OCS, and my PT scores challenge the 18-21 y.o. It's all about attitude and staying focused. Your son needs to get his foot in the door and everything will be gravy...never look back. The scare tactic speech is mostly aimed at those who used/abused illicit drugs. Your son will be facing a MedCom Physician who will be asking tons of personal questions; this is not a Polygraph exam. Do NOT admit to taking meds for an undiagnosed issue. In fact, what they want to hear for the most part is that you have not been on antibiotics or had any surgery (Lasik, etc..) in the past year. Depending on the type of meds they have a chart that will tell them the "statute of limitation" - say: Aspirin - 2 months. Nexium - 12 months etc... The problem is they won't tell you what the chart says until it's too late, for those of us that are honest, and then you get the boot - goodbye... Look at Lasik surgery for example: if you get a Lasik surgery before enlisting you can't enlist for a minimum of 1 year, but if you enlist and get Lasik surgery while enlisted ALL is Great...Uncle Sam just paid for it....!! Don't try to understand the logic, because it won't make any sense to most of us. You are just dealing with a bunch of trained monkeys who are trained at putting a stamp and an initial in the correct box...the rest they could careless. Make their lives easy and they will make your son's life easy too... it's that simple. (some are Judge-shopping to get away from their crimes - your son needs to be Recruiter-shopping to get what he wants and be happy) Cheers, Stan
2,402 posts since Aug 21, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Stan, your stories scare me  Is our military that effed up? Guess so. Or just government in general. At any rate, I am printing out your reponses and giving them to my son to read. He looks so hopeless right now.
That's freaking awesome that you're going to OCS! Best wishes to you!
Nita
Look, Active finally added signature lines!
87 posts since Jan 19, 2008
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Nita
Wish there something I could do as well but at this point, all I can offer is moral support.
I am in the Air Force but dont have a lot of connections in the recruiting world although I have one or two people I could check with just to see if you are getting a legitimate reason
I have had a loosely related experience. I was scheduled to move to Japan a few years ago...we sold our house but had not received our final orders yet (stupid move on my part). At any rate, we had to get family medical clearance to get our orders. Much to my utter shock, my family was denied clearance because my son was diagnosed with ADHD and ODD. Although his local psychiatrist was vert willing to sign off on the move, the hospital at the base in Japan said no way - could not handle it. And we are talking a major base just 20 minutes from Tokyo. This really threw us for a loop. I was working at the Pentagon at the time; a general was kind enough to make a call on my behalf but no dice. The rationale was that the medical community is spread so thin with deployments that they just dont have the staffs OCONUS to handle even what we consider pretty typical stuff. In the end, it worked out okay but it was a very upsetting experience for us all.
Keep the faith
Dave
2,503 posts since Dec 15, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Nita,
Not saying too much but send him to stayu with his sister in the Houston area for a few days and then follow Stan's advice. I am glad he beat me to the punch because I agree with him whole heartedly. Do not disclose anything that is not official and remember it is not a polygraph exam but a series of questions. It gives him the opportunity to examine other branches, like the beloved Corps. I would only advice him to stear clear of the Army (long very long continual deployments), but all other branches are doable. Remind him to not feel compelled to say anything that is not offical and that the only thing they test you for is drug use. That is all I would disclose with out them having any proof. The reason to send him to Houston is that he would end up at a different recruiter and MEPS station. Any questions you have my number and e-mail.
Jimmy
Running MCM in support of The Injured Marines Fund and Team Espirit De Corps!
http://1775.weebly.com/
Last Marathon: Air Force Marathon 9/20/08 3:19:37
Next Marathon: Chicago marathon 10/12/08 ???????
2,048 posts since Jan 23, 2008
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Once a young man (born in Denison TX) whose family had moved to Kansas couldn't get an appointment to Annapolis. A compatriot in the Texas Hill Country couldn't get one to West Point. Eventually, each settled for the best they could get from the government , with Mr. Eisenhower heading to West Point and Mr. Nimitz to Annapolis. Even screw-ups sometimes lead to good things!
2,402 posts since Aug 21, 2007
Re: The Department of Defense is full of sh!t.
Did I mention lately how much I love having you all as friends? Thank you, Jimmy, Dave, Stan, Holly, Omi, Kat... everyone.
Nita
P.S. Jimmy, the Houston idea is perfect.
Look, Active finally added signature lines!
|