This Question is Possibly Answered

1 "correct" answer available (10 pts) 2 "helpful" answers available (7 pts)
13 Replies Last post: Jun 29, 2008 2:25 PM by Guest  
Click to view AaronP's profile Expert 4 posts since
Jun 30, 2007
Reply

Apr 28, 2008 10:48 AM

Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?

Baseball at my high school was a big deal, and being in Arizona our team was able to play year-round in one league or another. Once you reached the varsity level it was pretty much expected that you drop all other sports and focus solely on baseball. Even the athletes who were also star players for the football team (i.e. the quarterback) were sometimes ostracized for their "outside" commitment.

Do you think athletes at the high school (varsity) level should focus only on one sport? Does it just depend on the athlete?

Reply
Click to view adam_sp's profile Community Moderator 27 posts since
Aug 31, 2007
1. Apr 30, 2008 2:49 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?

I think it depends on the athlete and it depends on the situation. If you are a true standout, a one of a kind talent, then I think you are more inclined to focus on one sport so you can be the best that you can be. But at the same time, it's simply up to the individual. If you truly love playing Football, Basketball and Baseball, so be it and go play. It's all about what the individual truly loves doing.


I remember when I was in high school. I was in a class of 55 kids, and 230 total in the entire high school. We were counted on to play sports and our participation was crucial to the success of the team. I played soccer, basketball and baseball and had a role on every single team that I played for throughout high school. It built great character, and prepared for me a lot of different situations in sports, and in life. It certainly has its benefits.

Click to view Jesse@Active's profile Community Moderator 34 posts since
Jul 3, 2007
2. Apr 30, 2008 4:44 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
I agree that it should be left up to the athlete. But at the same time, there definitely needs to be a mindset among athletic directors, coaches and parents to facilitate and encourage multi-sport participation. Coaches and parents wield great power when it comes to molding young minds.

I was lucky to have a h.s. baseball coach encourage me to swim during the winter to build arm strength, even though it cut into indoor baseball workouts. I went on to swim in college and now do a lot more in the pool and ocean then I do on the diamond. Most of my friends who just stuck with baseball now play a lot...of fantasy baseball.
Click to view joliversptv's profile Amateur 9 posts since
Mar 3, 2008
3. Apr 30, 2008 4:46 PM in response to: Jesse@Active
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
The more sports a kid plays, the better an athlete they become. In speaking with some college coaches, the encourage multi sport athletes. There is also a lesser chance of burnout in a particular sport.
Click to view Active_cjb's profile Expert 26 posts since
May 30, 2007
4. Apr 30, 2008 4:51 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
Personally, I'd encourage any HS kid to try as many sports as possible. HS athletics provides not only great memories, but builds friendships and teaches life skills. Typically, in our ESPN-dominated sports world, all the attention is focused on the top-100. That's absolutely not what HS sports is about. Very few of the kids playing in HS will ever play in college or beyond. Don't worry about playing 1, 2 or 3 sports.... just enjoy the experience.
Click to view Bryan2337's profile Community Moderator 43 posts since
Aug 21, 2007
5. May 1, 2008 8:34 AM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?

If a kid can excel at multiple sports then why try to stop them? At that age how do they know what they want to focus on. Life is much easier when you have options. Although the kid should recognizes that dedication to a single sport would make them better faster in that sport.

Click to view jbrowshsptv's profile Expert 41 posts since
Mar 3, 2008
6. May 1, 2008 9:01 AM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
I agree that athletes should be supported in playing multiple sports. Would Antonio Gates or Tony Gonzalez be as good athletically and as TEs in the NFL if they didn't play basketball in college? Would Donovan McNabb be as good a QB or Allen Iverson be as elusive a PG if they didn't play multiple sports? Would Chris Young be as versatile a pitcher if he didn't play basketball at princeton? It seems that college are pushing kids away from playing multiple sports, but I feel like having that variety makes you a better and more versatile athlete. Plus, as it was said above, it prevents burnout from one sport.

To give a person example, my friend plays both softball and soccer at a D-III school in Massachusetts (I interviewed her for a podcast and we talked about it go to Softballpower.tv, then features at the top, the interview is with Katie Hartman). She feels that playing multiple sports keeps her in better shape and helps her with school since she is never completely out of season and never loses that routine.

I understand that coaches want the kids to play one sport so they can reach their full potential in that discipline, but I feel the advantages of participating in multiple sports outweight the negatives of focusing on two different sports. We have to remember these are teenagers and their interests and focus change quickly, but having that option of a second sport to play helps avoid them getting tired of just a single sport.

Click to view Active Sara's profile Active.com Staff 995 posts since
Oct 2, 2007
7. May 12, 2008 8:37 PM in response to: jbrowshsptv
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
I played lacrosse in college, but I was into many sports whether it be competitively for school or outside school during high school. Of course I had to focus my efforts once I decided I would be playing lacrosse in college, but I still played basketball and soccer for my school. I dropped my very competitive club soccer team my sophomore year so I would have more time for lacrosse, but I think playing other sports benefited me on many levels.

First, I was in better shape year round. There were night lacrosse teams I could play on and I could work out on my own obviously, but there is nothing like playing in a game. I also feel like I kept that game "edge" and quick thinking since I was constantly in game settings. When I got back out on the lacrosse field I was mentally sharp. Also, I believe you learn a lot from playing other sports even if they are completely different. When I was being recruited there were several coaches that wanted to come see me play in a soccer or basketball game, which didn't really make sense to me at the time, but it does now.

I spent a year coaching lacrosse for University of Richmond and when we looked at recruits we didn't want someone who ONLY played lacrosse. We wanted an all around athlete, someone who was competitive and experienced as an athlete. You can't teach being an athlete, but every coach in college will develop you into a baseball player, hockey player, lacrosse player, etc. Baseball is obviously different from lacrosse, but I would think the majority of coaches would agree. They want you to be a focused player in your given sport, but they also want you to be an experienced athlete.

Lastly, enjoy high school sports. If you decide to play one sport in college you'll basically become that sport since the majority of your time is spent doing it. You don't want to get burnt out on that sport before you even get to college. Some of my best memories from high school are from soccer and basketball, not necessarily just lacrosse.
Guest
8. Jun 12, 2008 4:00 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
why do you think players from south america are better they play baseball all year long.and are perfecting there skills.
Guest
9. Jun 23, 2008 3:54 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
Athletes should never be asked to put blinders on in their sports career. In high school or college. Playing different sports gives most players an edge mentally and physically. Unless kids are being paid to play don't limit their day job. Sports.

www.depar727.blogspot.com

Guest
10. Jun 23, 2008 4:11 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
it depends on the sport. you have people that like more than oe sport and if they want to let them. for instance i like bowling and playing baseball and i do both in high school. if you are really good at a sport you can have collages looking at you for both or one or the other for scholarships to school. most importantly you might even find you career in that sport.
Guest
11. Jun 23, 2008 4:44 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?

No! I played 5 different sports this year in highschool! I'm a girl and I live in Ontario by the way...
Guest
12. Jun 26, 2008 3:03 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?
i think its up to that person but speaking form personal experience multi sports its ok but very demanding on that person i played football,baseball , track (shock putt) and power lifted for our school. Now ive got little ones and they play football ,baseball ,basketball,karate and its demanding so i think if you can do it why not just go for it you only live once but be careful good luck out thier
Guest
13. Jun 29, 2008 2:25 PM in response to: AaronP
Re: Should high school athletes focus on just one sport?

I'd have to agree with others it aint a clear cut answer. I'd also say it depends on the sport. I coach baseball and teach Physical Ed in Great Britain and here if your a soccer player its very hard being a 2 sport or more athlete, because soccer last 11 months of the year. British highschool students spend 39 weeks in school about 31 of those weeks soccer goes on, they play a lot of games and tournaments as a result soccer players usually don't make good 2 sport athletes and conversly baseball teams with lots of soccer players are not successful, because the players are either not available to play half the season and have not practiced. I coach an amateur adult team in the British AAA division one of my players is also a soccer player, I hardly ever see him. The only exception to this rule is one of my students who has practiced with me all year every week and worked very hard despite being a soccer player the downside was he missed the first half of the season, but he's put in the practice. Depends on the length and season of the other sport. I practiced karate and played baseball in college, but karate fitted in perfectly with baseball and was perfect for developing explosive power and speed. Depends on potential natural talent, demands of each. The best youth players in Great Britain with few exceptions are 1 sport athletes, but thats also a necessity of playing baseball in England.