UWHUSKY,
I also broke my pinky toe about 2 1/2 weeks ago. It was sticking out at an angle. I had to go get it x-ray'd at ER. I felt stupid because it was just a pinky toe. Well, good thing I did. It was broken in 2 places at an odd angle. The orthopedic guy had to reset it...NOT FUN. Now, that said, it doesn't change what/how a broken toe is managed. I have a boot/shoe that I must wear for a at least 3 weeks and 'buddy-tape' the two last toes together for about 6 weeks. I, like you, tried to run in a 5k the day after...didn't happen.
I would recommend going to have it x-ray'd just to ensure that the break isn't weird. You may never have it heal correctly. The break from running is killing me and of course, the reason for being on this board is to see if I can get some idea on when I can return. I have been spinning and riding the moutain bike, but nothing beats my running.
I would advise going to a podiatrist or orthopedic doc to get it on the road to recovery. The goal isn't to run tomorrow. THe goal is to run forever!
Good luck