active network espn
Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage
Cool Running homepage  Search Cool Running Community
Login to Reply
1 2 3 Previous Next
Click to view MaineRunner2001's profile Legend 267 posts since
Mar 15, 2002

Jun 25, 2007 1:33 PM

Thanks to tinman (sub 20 minute thread broken?)

I tried to post this a couple times on the sub 20 minute thread, but it didn't take:

I want to send kudos to tinman. The workouts he sent my way have made me very strong. Saturday, June 23 I set a PR in a 5-mile road race. The time was 34:17. Using that 5-mile time, McMillan predicts a 20:41 5K. I am much better at 5K distances then other distances. I think I have a very good chance of a sub 20 minute 5K this summer.

If anyone is interested, I created a blog that contains a race report. Check it out here: http://dhartley86.vox.com/library/post/gardiner-5-mile-road-race---june-23-2007.html[/URL" target="_blank">

Good running all.
Click to view Tracy Lightfoot's profile Pro 94 posts since
Oct 27, 2007
1. Jun 25, 2007 3:49 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
That's great, Maine. I'll add the link to my blogroll. I'm thinking about doing a running-centric blog on my end (I did one briefly while training for my first HM, for a local sports news site), and if I do, I'll post the link.

Should we start doing a weekly new thread, so we don't have to click through as much? Maybe on Monday evenings, or Sunday evenings?

I ran 20:41 on 6/16, so we're right at the same pace!

Can you send me those tinman workouts if you have them handy? tf(dot)lightfoot(at)insightbb(dot)com
Click to view MichiganFlyer's profile Legend 348 posts since
Dec 9, 2005
2. Jun 26, 2007 7:30 AM in response to: MaineRunner2001
Great race report Maine!

Nice to hear your thoughts during a race.
Also you can use your race reports to remember what helped and what hurt for later races.

I ran a 33:08 on the treadmill (with 0% incline) on 12-31-06
On 1-22-07 I ran a 19:14 5k on the treadmill (also 0% incline).

I went to a treadmill website and figured my 0% 5k time was equivalent to a 20:04 5k outdoors.The 5 mile treadmill time was equivalent to about 34:30 outdoors. So I would say you are fit enough to run a sub 20 5k right now if the right circumstances come together.Keep up the good work!
Click to view fredurie's profile Legend 1,979 posts since
Aug 21, 2002
4. Jun 26, 2007 9:13 AM in response to: MaineRunner2001
What does slow tempo pace do for you? Does it play a part
in moving your threshold?

McMillan has something called steady state ( 13 to 18 mile
race pace. Is this the same thing?
Click to view Dana Becker's profile Legend 392 posts since
Nov 20, 2007
5. Jun 26, 2007 11:12 AM in response to: MaineRunner2001
Well I am officially a member of the sub 20:00 club! Last Saturday night I shaved ~45 seconds off my PR from 3 weeks ago. (20:40) I was confident going in that I had a shot at 20:00 or better based on my last few tempo runs, but I wasn't sure I could really hold the pace. (or rather that I wanted to endure that much pain to be honest) I weighed in about 2 pounds lighter than 3 weeks ago, at 193.

My gun time was 19:54. Watch time of 19:52.

The course had a few good climbs/hills in the first 2 miles, but the 3rd mile flattened out with a slight downhill, which was a nice change of pace for the 5K's around here.

In comparing times to others who ran the last 5K with me, some ran a bit faster, but many ran slower. So I'm confident about the course measurement. It was also mid 80's and humid, so I'm sure that affected some runners quite a bit.

All in all, I'm very happy with it, as I definitely wasn't expecting to crack 20:00 this early on in the summer. I was shooting for middle of August.

However, this is a stepping stone in my bid to BQ this fall, as a sub 20:00 projects out to a BQ time for a marathon. At least I know I have the speed, as I've really been focusing on base mileage and losing weight since last August. (~1900 miles mostly at 70% or lower of max heart rate)

The previous 2 weeks before my fall back week (race week) I ran 127 miles. One tempo run and one interval session. Moderate hills during easy runs as well. Last week was 40 total including the race.

My training log is here: http://www.coolrunning.com/cgi-bin/log/display.cgi?u=Docster;s=run4life[/URL" target="_blank">

Best of luck folks!
Click to view SiriusFun's profile Amateur 9 posts since
Apr 3, 2007
6. Jun 26, 2007 1:25 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
Hi all,

First, Docster Congratulations!!!

Second,I?ve been meaning to post for a while now, but I was waiting until I got closer to the 20-minute mark. Here is a little background. I ran track in high school and my freshman year of college (D III), and competed in sprinting events (100 m PR 11.15, 200 M PR 23.00, 400 PR 52.05). After a 12-year layoff I started running again about 1 year ago. This past February I competed in a 5k and posted a 23:32. In April I posted a 22:22. Also in April is when I found Coolrunning, and in particular, the Sub 20 5k thread. So... what did incorporating the coaching (Tinman, Tchuck, et al) that I read on the Sub 20 5k thread do for me in a little under 3 months. Well Sunday morning I posted a 19:53! It was a perfect morning to run fast, cloudy and about 60 degrees at race time. I?m still not comfortable with my pacing for this distance, I went out a little fast, the first mile was 6:05. I felt good so I just tried to hang on. I wasn?t able to get any other splits because they didn?t mark the other miles. The course was 2 loops around a lake with 1 short (150m) steep incline and a corresponding decline, otherwise fairly flat. I tried to keep pace with a runner that I knew could beat 20 minutes. I was right with him until the second time up that incline, where he started to pull away. I picked it up on the downhill and tried to keep my focus on the runners in front of me and not on the burning in my legs. Coming down the home stretch, when I could see the finish, I glanced at my watch and had 20 seconds to get there before 20 min. I kicked as hard as I could and covered the distance in 13. I couldn?t believe it when I crossed the line and I heard the timer say 19:53. Sure enough I looked at my watch, which confirmed it. I finished 13th overall, and 2nd in my age group (30-39).

My training the past 3 months has been fairly consistent. I?ve been getting out for about 1 hour 5-6 days per week. Most days I run EZ, 1 day I will run either a four mile tempo or a 40 minute fartlek 60 seconds on 60 seconds off. On Saturdays 1 run 2 miles to the local track and do 5x 1000m CV intervals (Tinman these are awesome, they get you to run fast without killing yourself) with about 1 ½ min rest. Then I run home. If I am feeling good I will throw in another fartlek or tempo on one of the easy days (this hasn?t happened very much until recently). I live in very hilly area so every run that I do, EZ or otherwise, incorporates several good hills. I mostly run by time and by ?feel?, so I don?t know exactly what pace I am running most of the time, just a relative level of exertion on my part. I do have a 4-mile loop marked out and that is where I will do tempo runs. The EZ runs are a combination of off-road trail, and road running. The week leading up to this race I cut down significantly, mostly due to family things (apparently my wife and kid like spending time with me). I didn?t run Sunday 6/17 or Monday 6/18, Tuesday 6/19 was a 30 min fartlek, Wednesday 6/20 was 40 min EZ, Thursday 6/21 was 35 min fartlek, Friday 6/22 was 30 min EZ, and a big ol? zero on Saturday 6/23 (I really wanted to run, but it was 11 pm before I was able to get out and at that point I thought a good night?s sleep would be more beneficial).
Click to view markc7079's profile Pro 197 posts since
Sep 7, 2002
7. Jun 26, 2007 4:33 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
Way to go Docster!! Great work. I hope to join the club soon.

------------------
Mark

Vegan 100 Miler[/URL" target="_blank">
Click to view runfastcoach's profile Pro 122 posts since
Jan 25, 2006
8. Jun 27, 2007 1:48 AM in response to: MaineRunner2001
The McMillan steady state run mentioned is nothing but a ripoff from what I used to preach. I sent lots of information to his buddy Jonas Holdeman (who I didn't know was McMillan's buddy) and it was quickly convereted into "McMillan's" ideas. What baloney!

I used to define Stamina training as 30k race pace to slightly slower than marathon pace, and then McMillan starts writing about it as if he made it up.

I used to say the ideal distance to test VO2 max was 2500m (in truth, I never told Holdeman that I had calcuated to be 2516.66 meters). That showed up on McMillan's website. There has been many other things, too, which showed up there were either from the emails I sent to Holdeman to help him with some runners he was coaching at the university (in TN) or from posts I've made on letsrun.com from quite a ways back. So, anyone who quotes McMillan better think twice about the source and whether it is original.

You can tell it irks me that my stuff is ripped off. But, the good news is McMillan is always two steps behind me. He has to read my posts to get new information or else go back to quoting Arthur Lydiard - which is fine by me.

In case you are wondering, I never said that all my ideas are completely original. Many are, but the ones that do come from other sources are at these:

A long run each week is very important. It builds endurance like nothing else! That's from Lydiard

A semi-fast distance run once a week is a good idea. That's Lydiard too. He had his runners cover 10 miles at 3/4th effort once a week. That was about 5:30 pace for Snell...about what I would call Tinman Tempo or a Slow Tempo run pace. I ran this once a week under my first coach, but not as far, and he had me add 1 minute a mile to my 1-mile time. I later used statistics and calculus to find a more optimal pace, but the general idea is Lydiard's.

Running slow, longer intervals at an Aerobic pace is from Harry Wilson. Harry coached Steve Ovette to glory for GB, world records, and a gold medal in the Olympic Games. Harry had his runners, like Ovett, run reps on grass in a park about about 10k pace or a little slower. That's not too far away from my CV pace. Harry had his runners go by feel. I use calculus to derive an optimal pace and let the runner adjust it just a bit if need be. Ovett ran those long, aerobic repeats once a week for 15 years. I use the same concept. When I was a young runner, my coach used Slow intervals once a week, sometimes twice a week. They were never fast. Lots of 660 yard repeats at about 70% speed. I was breathing fairly good but it never felt hard. I was never "winded."

Running hill charges is something many of my runners do after base training is over. That's a Lydiard concept, but it is also one that the Brits have done for about a hundred years. I don't have my guys spring or bound up the hill like Lydiard did, but it doesn't mean that hills run at about 2-mile to 1-mile race effort aren't good for improving specific leg strenth. I ran 300 yard hills unde my first coach, for about a month, once a week, and would be about 97% of the way towards my best times, without having done race-pace training.

I prescribe combo workouts. That's a Bowerman idea. He had some runners, during the fall, especially, do a lot of running in a single workout, including distance running, some hills, and some 300s or 110s for quickness. I do that same thing. I learned about it from my first coach: He had us run 2 miles to a hill, do 6 x 300 yards at a good effort, jog 2 miles back to the track, run 6 x 200 at about 1-mile pace, jog 200, and then we'd run 2 miles of easy fartlek.

Anway, I want you to know that I have benefited from many good coaches who have offered their thoughts on training, and I am more than happy to give them credit, where it is due.

Hope you all have a great day!

Tinman
Click to view jmoleary's profile Pro 71 posts since
Sep 29, 2007
9. Jun 27, 2007 11:52 AM in response to: MaineRunner2001
quote:<HR>Originally posted by runfastcoach:
The McMillan steady state run mentioned is nothing but a ripoff from what I used to preach. I sent lots of information to his buddy Jonas Holdeman (who I didn't know was McMillan's buddy) and it was quickly convereted into "McMillan's" ideas. What baloney!<HR>


I'm late to this discussion.

Are you saying you invented steady state runs? Or are you saying you invented how he describes them?
Click to view runfastcoach's profile Pro 122 posts since
Jan 25, 2006
10. Jun 27, 2007 3:10 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
No, I certainly did not invent steady state runs.

I am saying that it bugs me when people quote McMillan about training when the articles he writes (like stamina or VO2 max pace) is information that he has taken from me without proper citation.

The information I discussed was direct information taken from emails in reply to Jonas Holdeman's questions. I did not know they were buddies and that Holdeman would pass all that data on to McMillan. What would have been the ethical thing to do is not only ask for my permission but at least a proper citation of my work. Common decency is all I was asking for!

Regardless, let's move on.

Take care,

Tinman
Click to view Dana Becker's profile Legend 392 posts since
Nov 20, 2007
11. Jun 27, 2007 3:15 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
Wow, I was just wondering the other day what steady state runs are. Thanks for sharing, Tinman! Good stuff as always.
Click to view MichiganFlyer's profile Legend 348 posts since
Dec 9, 2005
12. Jun 27, 2007 3:20 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
Docster,

Wow you ran a sub 20 at 193 pounds!
I guess the 60 mile weeks helped alot.
Congratulations!


Tinman,

You also have me curious.

Who do you coach?
And what were your best times when you were in your prime?
Why do you care so much for us to break the 20 minute barrier?
I don't mean to be nosy just curious.
Click to view runfastcoach's profile Pro 122 posts since
Jan 25, 2006
13. Jun 27, 2007 9:27 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
I coach about 25-30 runner, at one time, from around the world. Most are American, but I coach two Irishman, a Norwegian, a Belgian (not horse), and an Aussie, in addition to a Candian and several from the States.

People come and go, but right now I coach about 6 guys who are right near 31 minutes in the 10k, a few masters (40 to 61) who are at the top of their age groups.

I coached a lad from Texas since late November of 2004. He went from being a 4:51 miler to a state champ in the 5k xcountry (15:15) (Texas 4A champ) to the state champ in the 3200m (9:16) this spring. Watch for him to be an Olympic Trials qualifier in 2012. His name is Drew Bean.

In the past, I coached a couple top-flight runner. I coached Sonia O'Sullivan for 4 months, but then plans changed when she was given Australian citizenship and her man, Nic Bideau made arrrangements for her to run the 5k for the Australian team at the Commonwealth Games. Nic took over her training at that point. But, Sonia was making good progress (after a horrible 2 years prior to my coaching her).

I've coached a guy was 12th in the Olympic Trials marathon. He was just a plain hard worker. THe hardest thing was holding him back and giving him workouts that left him fresh.

Several university teams have used my training. Coaches from the following universities have contacted me and asked for advice: University of Wisconsin- La Crosse, University of IL- Chicago, University of WI - Eau Claire, Washington University, University of Illinois, University of Idaho, University of Nevada - Reno, and North Dakota State University.

Several high school coaches have used my training, too, Two, of the top, have won state titles using it: since they are my friends, I won't say their school names, but they are from Wisconsin and Maryland.

I've been a coach-advisor to several top high school runners. Just one I can say, for sure, since I know her father doesn't mind if I say something: Lauren Saylor of California who was a top 20 runner at Footlocker, before.

Ive' advised some top open coaches on training, too. Nic Bideau, Brad Hudson, a coach whose name is escaping me (I should know it since he's contacted me a few times) from
Scotland, and Knut Kvalheim, from Norway.

About my own running, it was modest. I had a very sub-par collegiate career. Much of that was due to having compartment syndrome in both lower legs. I had surgery on it just before my 20th birthday. I had terrible swelling, still do, and lots of restrictions on how far I could run. I ached every second of every day, taking huge doses of Ibuprofen just to get to sleep. In high school, I ran close to 16 minutes in the 5k (roads) and in the mid to upper 15s in x-country (3 miles, most of the time).

I played basketball in the winters, so had practically no aerobic endurance come spring...which for me takes about 6 months or more to build. I had a best of 1:59.88 in the 800 and 4:32 in the 1600m, although I probably had my fastest time on a 447 yard (yeah, it was long) home track in which I ran the 1788 yards in 4:36 in the distance medley relay, after running the 2 mile. I lost by 1 second to a guy who had run 4:19 for the 1600m.

As a freshman at Southern IL Univeristy, I red-shirted from the team. Coach Bill Cornell told me that I needed to run 4:10 to make the team, and that was too fast for me. I ran all winter on my own - about 50 miles per week, doing tempos over hilly terrain, lots of striders either on the soccer fields or on the track. I never did a single 400m repeat workout or the like, but ran 4:23 in a mile (not 1600m) in an on-campus road-race that was operated by the Student Union. I was second to a guy that ran 4:20 (who was on the university team).

The next few years I ran for a D3 school, was injured almost the whole time. I had surgery as a sophomore and was never the same. I couldn't run more than 40 miles per week and survive the pain in my legs. It greatly hurt my chances of advancing my fitness. I ran a lot of hard interval workouts, whatever was written, faithfully, and it ruined my aerobic endurance. I'd run my fastest times in the first week or two of the season and then get worse. I'd come off a 35-40 mile per week base, run well, then get worse and worse.

In my late 20s, I had run steadily for about 2 years, missing less than 5 days total. I found a routine that worked well for me: Day 1 (Easy)(7:30 per mile), Day 2 (Medium) (7:00 to 6:45 per mile), Day 3 (Semi-Strong, Tempo Running) (6:15 to 6:00 per mile over rolling hills). I was working a lot of hours, on my feet a lot, so I was tired all the time. That fact alone probably cost me 15-30 seconds per mile in my pace. But, I ran 15:13 on the track for 5,000m and 4:01.98 off that training. No speedwork, other than pickup basketball games!

Just after that, I got terrible kidney stones from all the Ibuprofen and Aleve I was consuming just to run daily. It hit me hard and my urologist told me to stop taking the meds. I had to! I stopped competitive running at that point, althought I jumped in some cycling and duathlon races on limited running training.

Must get some dinner!

Take care,

Tinman
runfastcoach@gmail.com
Click to view MichiganFlyer2's profile Pro 160 posts since
May 13, 2007
14. Jun 27, 2007 9:27 PM in response to: MaineRunner2001
5k on the treadmill in 19:07 tonight...a treadmill record by 7 seconds that I set in January.

I am going on vacation so I won't be able to run tomorrow. I wasn't sure I could run today but around 9pm I decided to go for a couple miles on the treadmill. As soon as I started I knew I could run fast. Very old shoes and 0.20 mile warmup and away I went.

6:18 mile 1
6:14 mile 2 (still felt very easy)
6:04 mile 3

1st 1.5 miles was 9:25
2nd 1.5 miles was 9:11

There aren't many days when I feel this good. I think this equates to a 19:57 five-k outdoors. Although the treadmill is hard to compare to outside times when I break treadmill records I know I am in better shape. And this run was pretty easy.

I am looking at a morning 5k race outdoors on July 7.