When it comes to brands I think getting input from others is great.  When it comes to which type to wear I would rely on what a local running store says.  That is the way to combine someone who is knowledgeable with running with someone who is actually looking at your feet and stride.

For me, Asics have always been the most comfortable.  My podiatrist told me a couple of years ago he tends to see the least amount of injuries from Saucony wearers.

I think the bottom line is the best shoe is likely the one that feels best for you.

Jim

I wear Brooks..started in Dyads; now I'm in Adrenalines.  Go to your local running store (Fleet Feet, etc) and they should be able to find just the shoe for you.

I'm fairly new to running; been using my New Balance cross-trainers.  Switching to the extra-wides for my duck feet made a huge difference.

I run in the Saucony Guide 3.  They are the most amazing running shoe I have encountered.  They have so much support and fit like a glove.  I had a stress fracture in February due to worn out New Balances so I went to a specialty shop to get fitted for a new pair.  The Saucony Guide 3 was recommended to me and I instantly fell in love when trying them on.  I am due for a new pair in May and will continue to buy this shoe.  I highly recommend Saucony for the support.  I personally despise Nike running shoes.  I also feel that their new Lunar Glide Elite is a poor excuse for support.  I tried them on and they have virtually no support.  Def go to a specialty shop if you can and try on a few pairs based on store recommendations.

A running shoe store in my town (Nashville) fit me in Brooks Adrenaline 4 years ago.  I have had a stress fracture and a baby since then and feel I need to be refitted (not that I'm still wearing that same pair!  I'm NOT!)  I was told I over-pronate but just mildly.  I currently run in Asics 2150's and love them, but for some reason lately have just felt like I'm either not an overpronator or there is still a better shoe out there FOR ME.  I think I will be going to Fleet Feet next (different than my original store) and soon to see how I'm running these days.

I definitely agree with you about color.  I could give a crap less now.  The shoes get recycled at Nike by me every 4 months now anyway.  In the past I used to buy shoes based on their "cuteness" and then I learned the hard way with a stress fracture.

I will echo what many others have already posted.  You should go to a running specialty store and have your foot/gait analyzed.  After working for a specialty running store for many years I can't stress enough the importance of having this done.  Brand, in my opinion, isn't really important, as long as it's a reputable brand ( ie Asics, Mizuno, Brooks, Nike, Saucony, Pearl Izumi, etc.).  I have tried about every brand imaginable, but I always go back to Mizuno &/or Brooks.  I currently run in Mizuno Wave Rider 13s and love them.

My suggestion is to have an open mind when trying on shoes, and try on several ( 4 pair minimum) and choose the one that feels right.  Trust me, one will stand out above the rest.  The best shoe for you is the one that feels the best to you!  Also, check the store's return policy.  Many specialty stores will allow you to return the shoes if they do not feel right after the first few days/runs.

Hope this helps!

J B