active network espn

Currently Being Moderated

The Serena Incident

Posted by inside_tennis on Sep 14, 2009 1:48:37 PM

 

 

Arguing with officials is nothing new in tennis.

 

John McEnroe in his day was, arguably, the king of on-court discrepancies. Not to be forgotten is Ilie Nastase's 18-minute boycott during the 1979 U.S. Open disputing a line call by the chair umpire. The tradition continues today with Andy Roddick, whose no slacker at giving a linesperson what for.

 

But what transpired Saturday night at the U.S. Open women's semi-final between Serena Williams and an U.S. Open official has taken things to a new level. Regardless of the validity of the call that claimed Serena made a foot fault, Williams' 10-second berating of the official goes beyond the realm of poor conduct.

 

"I swear to God I'm (expletive) going to take this (expletive) ball and shove it down your (expletive) throat, you hear that? I swear to God," Williams said to the official.

 

The context: Kim Clijsters lead Serena one set to love, with Serena serving at 15-30 in the second to send the set into a tiebreaker. Serena lost her temper after the lineswoman called a foot fault, resulting in a double-fault. That moved Clijsters one point from victory. Williams then was penalized a point for a second outburst towards the linesperson. Because it happened to come on match point, it ended the semifinal with Clijsters winning 6-4, 7-5.

 

Williams was fined $10,000 Sunday for unsportsmanlike conduct and could face further penalties -- including a higher fine and a possible suspension -- for what U.S. Open tournament director Jim Curley described as her "threatening manner."

 

After what I'm sure was a good deal of pressure from her team and corporate sponsors, Serena issued this amendment on Monday to her previous press release:

 

Hey guys!!!
I want to amend my press statement of yesterday, and want to make it clear as possible — I want to sincerely apologize FIRST to the lines woman, Kim Clijsters, the USTA, and tennis fans everywhere for my inappropriate outburst. I’m a woman of great pride, faith and integrity, and I admit when I’m wrong.
I need to make it clear to all young people that I handled myself inappropriately and it’s not the way to act — win or lose, good call or bad call, in any sport, in any manner.
I like to lead by example. We all learn from experiences both good and bad. I will learn and grow from this, and be a better person as a result.
Xxxx,
S

Although she has finally and offically apologized, her behavior begs the question, "Should Serena be suspended from professional tennis for her unsportsmanlike conduct?"

1,432 Views Tags: open, us, williams, serena, clijsters


Sep 14, 2009 4:02 PM RyanActive RyanActive    says:

Suspended? Good God no. Her conduct was nothing new. Fiery athletes do it all the time. MLB managers would make you blush with the things they say to umpires. What Venus did was no worse than what McEnroe did about a billion times.

 

Personally, I'm glad that a money-up-to-her-eyeballs athlete shows a heck of a lot of passion for winning a tournament she's already won three times. She probably shouldn't have told the line judge she'd make her choke on a tennis ball, but that's why she got the penalty point and the fine. That's plenty.

Sep 15, 2009 6:43 AM TenaciousO TenaciousO    says in response to RyanActive:

Suspend her and make her be a line judge for a match.  Let her get yelled at by a player.  If a football or basketball player threatened a ref they would be thrown out of the game, fined and suspended.  This tirade goes against the "classy" and "civilized" appearance that tennis tries to uphold.

Sep 15, 2009 4:47 PM barcapone barcapone    says:

Sorry Ryan I have to respectfully disagree, at least in part. While I too am glad that she still has the passion for the game, this kind of unsportswoman like conduct diminishes the sport and professional sports in general when so blithely addressed. 10K to Ms Williams is a drop in the bucket.. no more than you or I coughing up a twenty, if that much.

This kind of behavior is rampant in sports because it IS let slide.  If your or I did it, we would have a sanction worth remembering, she should have no less.

Sep 15, 2009 4:59 PM Greyracer04 Greyracer04    says:

Suspension from next year's Open would be extreme.  If she had made physical contact with or threw the ball at the line judge, then yes.  She kept a good distance & dropped the ball by her side.  Suspension from the next few WTA events, maybe, but I'd still vote no.  However, a large financial fine would be suitable.  She doesn't have a history of these type of actions and is generally regarded as an honest player - that needs to be taken into consideration.  She's already been fined $10K and I heard she might be fined another $250K.  That sounds sufficient to me.

 

What she did was unacceptable, cannot be justified and there should be zero tolerance for.  Nobody is perfect and we've all overreacted at one time or another.  She was having a very frustrating match, it was obvious she was angry even before the call, and snapped.  Assuming she is sincere in here apology & she's been fined some $260K, it's time to move on.

Sep 16, 2009 7:41 AM StartedLate StartedLate    says:

Neither physical talent, passion for winning, "everybody else does it", nor seeding in the top 5 are excuses to tolarate unsportsmanlike conduct from ANY athlete. 

 

She paid a very costly price (losing the quarter finals) for her mistake, but had this happened earlier in the set, 2 points and $10,000 would have been too soft.  I support suspension from the next WTA tournament.  (it happens in soccer: 2 cumulative yellow cards and you're NOT playing the next game).